Super Early Top 400 for 2021

Super Early Top 400 for 2021

Usually when I post rankings, I'm ranking prospects or players for dynasty leagues. However, since I am participating in what to my knowledge are the first two NFBC Draft Champions slow drafts for 2021 (run by @draftchampagne), I started ranking players and figured I'd share those rankings with our subscribers.

I usually do my own projections every winter, which greatly informs my decisions in drafts every March, so these rankings could change drastically over the next four months. Consider these a pre-projections ranking set.

First, I have some general thoughts about the player pool for next year.

  • The top-12 is a clear top tier. I think you can be happy with your roster construction selecting any of those players in the first round, but I'm much less enthusiastic about starting my team with anyone outside that group of 12.
  • The closer we get to Opening Day, the higher the starting pitchers will move up my board as our confidence level in their health for OD nears 100 percent.
  • I think you need to approach things with the expectation of getting double-digit steals from every middle infielder and outfielder in your starting lineup. For every spot you don't get a double-digit steal guy, you need to get those steals from another player on your roster. So, let's say you want to roster Corey Seager or Eloy Jimenez, you could get Daulton Varsho as your catcher or Ke'Bryan Hayes as your third baseman and all of a sudden you're getting

Usually when I post rankings, I'm ranking prospects or players for dynasty leagues. However, since I am participating in what to my knowledge are the first two NFBC Draft Champions slow drafts for 2021 (run by @draftchampagne), I started ranking players and figured I'd share those rankings with our subscribers.

I usually do my own projections every winter, which greatly informs my decisions in drafts every March, so these rankings could change drastically over the next four months. Consider these a pre-projections ranking set.

First, I have some general thoughts about the player pool for next year.

  • The top-12 is a clear top tier. I think you can be happy with your roster construction selecting any of those players in the first round, but I'm much less enthusiastic about starting my team with anyone outside that group of 12.
  • The closer we get to Opening Day, the higher the starting pitchers will move up my board as our confidence level in their health for OD nears 100 percent.
  • I think you need to approach things with the expectation of getting double-digit steals from every middle infielder and outfielder in your starting lineup. For every spot you don't get a double-digit steal guy, you need to get those steals from another player on your roster. So, let's say you want to roster Corey Seager or Eloy Jimenez, you could get Daulton Varsho as your catcher or Ke'Bryan Hayes as your third baseman and all of a sudden you're getting those steals from a non OF/SS/2B spot and not falling behind.
  • I think it's important to significantly discount outfielders or middle infielders who don't run and don't hit for a high average. I'm specifically thinking of the Jorge Soler, Kyle Schwarber types. There's not much positional stolen-base opportunity cost when you roster Matt Olson or Eugenio Suarez, but there is when you don't secure those stats in the outfield or middle infield.
  • First base is no longer shallow relative to shortstop or outfield. In fact, I want to make a point of waiting and landing someone like Garrett Cooper, Rowdy Tellez or Brandon Belt for as long as the market is discounting those types.
  • Second base is the shallowest of the non-catcher hitting positions. If I miss out on the top guys and miss out on the Jake Cronenworth, Dylan Moore, Tommy Edman, Chris Taylor group, then I'm probably ending up with a Met, either Robinson Cano or Andres Gimenez.
  • I'm extremely cautious right now with regards to injured pitchers and am favoring starting pitchers whom I'm confident can log a heavy workload in 2021. I'm not drafting Roberto Osuna, Kirby Yates, Corey Kluber, James Paxton, A.J. Puk, Spencer Howard etc... until I see them on a mound looking like their healthy selves, and I'd still be discounting them even at that point.
  • I'm bumping up the elite closers, given how uncertain the position is after the top 10 or so.

I have included the positions each hitter is eligible at in the NFBC for 2021 (seven games is the cutoff for eligibility) along with some contractual, health and skill notes.

1Ronald AcunaOF 
2Fernando TatisSS 
3Trea TurnerSS 
4Juan SotoOF 
5Mookie BettsOF 
6Mike TroutOF*2 SB attempts in 53 games
7Jose Ramirez3B 
8Trevor StorySS 
9Christian YelichOF 
10Shane BieberSP 
11Jacob deGromSP 
12Gerrit ColeSP 
13Freddie Freeman1B 
14Bryce HarperOF 
15Bo BichetteSS 
16Ozzie Albies2B 
17Trevor BauerSP*Free agent
18Lucas GiolitoSP 
19Luis CastilloSP 
20Yu DarvishSP 
21Cody Bellinger1B/OF 
22Tim AndersonSS 
23Francisco LindorSS 
24Walker BuehlerSP 
25Xander BogaertsSS 
26Luis RobertOF 
27Adalberto MondesiSS 
28Kyle TuckerOF 
29Trent GrishamOF 
30Starling MarteOF*$12.5 million club option
31Clayton KershawSP*Downgraded due to back spasms
32Eloy JimenezOF 
33Manny Machado3B 
34Corey SeagerSS 
35DJ LeMahieu2B/3B*Free agent
36Brandon WoodruffSP 
37Jose Abreu1B 
38Jack FlahertySP 
39Max ScherzerSP 
40Tyler GlasnowSP 
41J.T. RealmutoC*Free agent
42Aaron NolaSP 
43Zac GallenSP 
44Max FriedSP 
45Zach PlesacSP 
46Nolan Arenado3B*Downgraded due to shoulder injury
47Alex Bregman3B 
48Anthony Rendon3B 
49Dansby SwansonSS 
50Whit Merrifield2B/OF 
51Lance LynnSP 
52Blake SnellSP 
53Kenta MaedaSP 
54Hyun Jin RyuSP 
55Rafael Devers3B 
56Marcell OzunaOF*Free agent
57George SpringerOF*Free agent
58Brandon Lowe2B/OF 
59Aaron JudgeOF 
60Teoscar HernandezOF 
61Carlos CarrascoSP 
62Josh HaderRP 
63Aroldis ChapmanRP 
64Luke Voit1B 
65Pete Alonso1B 
66Kenley JansenRP 
67Liam HendriksRP*Free agent
68Vladimir Guerrero1B 
69Paul Goldschmidt1B 
70Gleyber TorresSS 
71Ketel Marte2B 
72Cavan Biggio2B/3B/OF 
73Keston Hiura2B 
74Javier BaezSS 
75Dominic Smith1B/OF 
76Lourdes GurrielOF 
77Nelson CruzUT*Free agent
78Wil MyersOF 
79Kyle HendricksSP 
80Sandy AlcantaraSP 
81Sonny GraySP 
82Dylan BundySP 
83Pablo LopezSP 
84Stephen StrasburgSP*Downgraded due to hand surgery
85Corbin BurnesSP*Downgraded due to oblique injury
86Sixto SanchezSP 
87Edwin DiazRP 
88Nick AndersonRP 
89Matt Olson1B 
90Max Muncy1B/2B/3B 
91Yoan Moncada3B 
92Eugenio Suarez3B 
93Michael ConfortoOF 
94Nick CastellanosOF 
95Mike YastrzemskiOF 
96Jose Altuve2B 
97Charlie BlackmonOF 
98Gio Urshela3B 
99Framber ValdezSP 
100Zack WheelerSP 
101Jesus LuzardoSP 
102Zack GreinkeSP 
103Trevor RosenthalRP*Free agent
104Brad HandRP*$10 million club option
105Raisel IglesiasRP 
106Austin MeadowsOF*May sit against most LHP; has peaked as a runner
107Dustin MaySP 
108Jose BerriosSP 
109Randy ArozarenaOF*37.7 K% against RHP
110Alex VerdugoOF 
111Kyle LewisOF 
112Jeff McNeil2B/3B/OF 
113Michael BrantleyOF*Free agent
114Franmil ReyesUT 
115Giancarlo StantonUT 
116Eddie RosarioOF*Final year of arbitration
117J.D. MartinezOF 
118Matt Chapman3B*Downgraded due to hip surgery
119Ke'Bryan Hayes3B*Sneaky 15-steal upside at 3B
120Jake Cronenworth1B/2B/SS 
121Byron BuxtonOF*Downgraded due to concussion
122Dylan Moore2B/OF 
123Tommy Edman3B/2B/SS/OF*Best positional eligibility combo on the board
124Carlos CorreaSS 
125Ramon LaureanoOF 
126Chris Taylor2B/SS/OF 
127Taylor RogersRP 
128Ian AndersonSP 
129Julio UriasSP 
130Marco GonzalesSP 
131Kevin GausmanSP*Free agent
132German MarquezSP 
133Tony GonsolinSP 
134Lance McCullersSP 
135Mike ClevingerSP*Downgraded due to elbow injury
136Travis d'ArnaudC 
137A.J. PollockOF 
138Andrew McCutchenOF 
139Will Smith (LAD)C 
140Salvador PerezC 
141Dylan CarlsonOF 
142Tommy PhamOF*Final year of arbitration
143Yasmani GrandalC 
144Mike SorokaSP*Downgraded due to Achilles surgery
145Mike Moustakas1B/2B 
146Alec Bohm1B/3B 
147Clint FrazierOF*Very high ceiling, but still some playing time uncertainty
148Chris PaddackSP 
149Justin Turner3B*Free agent
150Anthony Rizzo1B*$16.5 million club option
151Randal GrichukOF 
152Anthony SantanderOF 
153Didi GregoriusSS*Free agent
154Sean MurphyC 
155Austin NolaC 
156Alex ColomeRP*Free agent
157Tyler MahleSP 
158Chris BassittSP 
159Aaron CivaleSP 
160David PriceSP 
161Cristian JavierSP 
162Ryan PresslyRP 
163Frankie MontasSP 
164Lorenzo CainOF 
165Victor RoblesOF 
166Austin Riley3B 
167Yordan AlvarezUT*Downgraded due to knee surgery
168Ian HappOF 
169Mark CanhaOF 
170Eric Hosmer1B 
171Jesse WinkerOF 
172Joey GalloOF 
173Gavin Lux2B 
174Jarred KelenicOF 
175Wander FrancoSS 
176Dinelson LametSP*Downgraded due to elbow injury
177Charlie MortonSP*$15 million team option
178Patrick CorbinSP 
179Craig KimbrelRP*Will have the job and was awesome from 8/14 on
180Garrett Cooper1B 
181Kyle SchwarberOF 
182Rowdy Tellez1B 
183Rhys Hoskins1B*Downgraded due to elbow surgery
184Jorge SolerOF 
185Max KeplerOF 
186Kris Bryant3B*Non-tender candidate
187Ryan Mountcastle1B/OF 
188Jared Walsh1B 
189Giovanny GallegosRP 
190James KarinchakRP 
191Willson ContrerasC 
192Christian VazquezC 
193Robinson Cano2B 
194Brian Anderson3B 
195Aaron HicksOF 
196Jo AdellOF 
197James McCannC*Free agent
198Ha Seong KimSS*Free agent, 20/20 upside
199Andres Gimenez2B/3B/SS 
200Daulton VarshoC/OF*15-steal threat at C
201John MeansSP 
202Joe MusgroveSP 
203Jordan MontgomerySP 
204Yusei KikuchiSP 
205Ryan YarbroughSP 
206Michael PinedaSP 
207Kyle Seager3B 
208Leody TaverasOF 
209Kole CalhounOF 
210David Fletcher2B/3B/SS 
211Jose UrquidySP 
212Nate PearsonSP 
213Rafael MonteroRP 
214Brandon Belt1B 
215Miguel Sano1B 
216Jeimer Candelario1B/3B 
217Brady SingerSP 
218Mike MayersRP 
219Masahiro TanakaSP*Free agent
220Drew PomeranzRP 
221Gary SanchezC 
222Kwang Hyun KimSP 
223Zach DaviesSP 
224Kyle WrightSP 
225Nathan EovaldiSP 
226Triston McKenzieSP 
227Mitch GarverC 
228Marcus StromanSP*Free agent
229Willy AdamesSS 
230Jurickson Profar2B/OF*Free agent, was a great fit with SD
231Jonathan Villar2B/SS*Free agent, don't assume he lands with everyday at-bats
232Shohei OhtaniUT*No idea how he will be deployed in 2021
233Manuel MargotOF*Will sit against some RHP
234Devin WilliamsRP*Downgraded due to shoulder injury
235Austin HaysOF 
236Victor ReyesOF 
237Andrew HeaneySP 
238J.D. Davis3B/OF 
239Jesus Aguilar1B 
240Andrew BenintendiOF 
241Richard RodriguezRP 
242Trey Mancini1B/OF*Expected back for spring training
243Carlos Santana1B*$16.5 million club option
244Josh Donaldson3B*Downgraded due to calf injury
245Marcus SemienSS*Free agent
246Jorge PolancoSS 
247Tommy La Stella2B/1B*Free agent
248Jean Segura2B/3B 
249David PeraltaOF 
250Joey BartC 
251Max StassiC 
252Bryan ReynoldsOF 
253Christian Walker1B 
254Miguel RojasSS 
255Cesar Hernandez2B*Free agent
256Jon Berti2B/OF 
257Joey Wendle2B/3B/SS 
258Alex KirilloffOF 
259Brandon NimmoOF 
260Yandy Diaz3B 
261Adam DuvallOF 
262Evan White1B 
263Edwin Rios3B*Justin Turner is a free agent
264MacKenzie GoreSP 
265Tejay AntoneSP*Trevor Bauer and Anthony DeSclafani are free agents
266Cal QuantrillSP 
267Casey MizeSP*Needs to lean on secondary offerings
268Clarke SchmidtSP 
269Griffin CanningSP 
270Eduardo RodriguezSP*Hopeful for normal offseason
271Seth LugoSP 
272Trevor RogersSP 
273Jameson TaillonSP 
274Domingo GermanSP 
275Deivi GarciaSP 
276Tarik SkubalSP 
277Josh LindblomSP 
278Jake OdorizziSP*Free agent
279Dallas KeuchelSP 
280Greg HollandRP*Free agent
281Mark MelanconRP*Free agent
282Brad KellerSP 
283Jorge AlfaroC 
284Pedro SeverinoC 
285Ryan JeffersC 
286Danny JansenC 
287Alejandro KirkC 
288Jason HeywardOF 
289Avisail GarciaOF 
290Eduardo Escobar3B 
291Andrew Vaughn1B 
292Michael KopechSP 
293Ryan McMahon1B/2B/3B 
294Isiah Kiner-Falefa3B/SS 
295Jordan RomanoRP 
296Will Smith (ATL)RP 
297Yasiel PuigOF*Free agent
298Bobby Dalbec1B 
299Jazz Chisholm2B/SS 
300Justus SheffieldSP*Will struggle against strong right-handed lineups
301Zach EflinSP*Will struggle against strong left-handed lineups
302Dane DunningSP*Will struggle against strong left-handed lineups
303Taijuan WalkerSP*Free agent
304Nick Solak2B/3B/OF 
305Josh Bell1B*Non-tender candidate
306Mauricio Dubon2B/SS/OF 
307Renato Nunez1B 
308Daniel BardRP 
309Yadier MolinaC 
310Yan GomesC 
311Nate Lowe1B 
312Nick Madrigal2B*Downgraded due to shoulder surgery
313Willi CastroSS/3B 
314Kevin PillarOF*Free agent
315J.P. CrawfordSS 
316Nick SenzelOF 
317Luis Urias2B/3B/SS 
318Ty France2B 
319Gregory PolancoOF 
320Alex DickersonOF 
321Bryse WilsonSP 
322Luis PatinoSP 
323Hunter Dozier1B/OF 
324Mitch HanigerOF 
325David PetersonSP 
326Brandon KintzlerRP*$4 million club option
327Andrew KnappC 
328Joey Votto1B 
329Mitch KellerSP 
330Diego CastilloRP 
331Chris MartinRP 
332Jeter Downs2B 
333Chris SaleSP*Tommy John surgery in March of 2020
334Noah SyndergaardSP*Tommy John surgery in March of 2020
335Luis SeverinoSP*Tommy John surgery in February of 2020
336Elieser HernandezSP*Downgraded due to shoulder injury
337Luke WeaverSP 
338Nick PivettaSP 
339Matthew BoydSP 
340Dylan CeaseSP 
341Drew SmylySP 
342JaCoby JonesOF 
343Sam HilliardOF 
344Jackie BradleyOF*Free agent
345Adam EatonOF*$10.5 million club option
346Andrelton SimmonsSS*Free agent
347Garrett Hampson2B/OF 
348Nick AhmedSS 
349Austin SlaterOF*Short-side platoon risk
350Thomas HatchSP 
351Kris BubicSP 
352David DahlOF 
353Jordan HicksRP 
354Zack BrittonRP*Can opt out if $14 million club option for 2022 isn't exercised
355Daniel HudsonRP 
356Stefan CrichtonRP 
357Myles StrawOF*George Springer, Michael Brantley, Josh Reddick are free agents
358Kolten Wong2B*$12.5 million club option
359Tanner HouckSP 
360Corey DickersonOF 
361Freddy PeraltaRP 
362Spencer TurnbullSP 
363Keegan AkinSP 
364Aaron BummerRP 
365Austin AdamsRP 
366Blake TreinenRP*Free agent
367Lucas SimsRP 
368Raimel TapiaOF 
369Donovan Solano2B 
370Martin MaldonadoC 
371Jacob StallingsC 
372Omar NarvaezC 
373Carson KellyC 
374Wilmer Flores2B/1B 
375Paul DeJongSS 
376Harrison BaderOF 
377Amed RosarioSS 
378Starlin Castro2B 
379Michael Chavis1B/2B/OF 
380Joc PedersonOF*Free agent
381Taylor WardOF 
382Hanser Alberto2B 
383Maikel Franco3B 
384Colin Moran1B 
385Luis Arraez2B 
386Carter Kieboom3B 
387Robbie GrossmanOF*Free agent
388Shin-Soo ChooOF*Free agent
389Luis Garcia2B 
390Jared OlivaOF 
391C.J. Cron1B*Free agent
392Yoshi Tsutsugo3B/OF 
393Adam Frazier2B/OF 
394Edward CabreraSP 
395Logan GilbertSP 
396Jackson KowarSP 
397Adrian MorejonRP 
398Adbert AlzolaySP*Will struggle against strong left-handed lineups
399Corbin MartinSP 
400Josh StaumontRP 

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
James Anderson
James Anderson is RotoWire's Lead Prospect Analyst, Assistant Baseball Editor, and co-host of Farm Fridays on Sirius/XM radio and the RotoWire Prospect Podcast.
MLB: Winter Meetings Recap
MLB: Winter Meetings Recap
Offseason Deep Dives: Garrett Crochet
Offseason Deep Dives: Garrett Crochet
Farm Futures: Rookie Infielder Targets
Farm Futures: Rookie Infielder Targets
Collette Calls: Does Controlling the Running Game Really Matter?
Collette Calls: Does Controlling the Running Game Really Matter?