Exploiting the Matchups: Week 17 Start/Sit

Exploiting the Matchups: Week 17 Start/Sit

This article is part of our Exploiting the Matchups series.

Week 17 always has an added layer of challenge, trying to sort out all the injuries, "injuries", and rest situations. As of Thursday morning, the Chiefs and Steelers are expected to rest their starting QBs, but that's about all we've seen in terms of announcements/declarations.

While Kansas City is the only team locked into a specific playoff spot, there are three others — Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Tampa — that already qualified for the tournament and can only rise or fall by one seed. The Steelers apparently don't care about the difference between the No. 2 seed and No. 3, so it'll be interesting to see how Buffalo responds.

The Bucs have a little more to play for, as a win assures them of a first-round matchup with the NFC East champ, while a Week 17 loss could lead to a game against the Saints or Seahawks next weekend. That sounds pretty significant to me, but we already saw Bruce Arians remove Tom Brady at halftime last week, so don't be too surprised if key players are removed early or don't handle their typical workloads.

In terms of the non-playoff teams, it's a little tougher to figure things out. They won't usually bench their starters, but it is fairly common in the season finale to give backups more playing time than usual. 

One team I'm a little wary of is Atlanta, who could still draft as early as third overall or as late as ninth. I don't think the Falcons will bench

Week 17 always has an added layer of challenge, trying to sort out all the injuries, "injuries", and rest situations. As of Thursday morning, the Chiefs and Steelers are expected to rest their starting QBs, but that's about all we've seen in terms of announcements/declarations.

While Kansas City is the only team locked into a specific playoff spot, there are three others — Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Tampa — that already qualified for the tournament and can only rise or fall by one seed. The Steelers apparently don't care about the difference between the No. 2 seed and No. 3, so it'll be interesting to see how Buffalo responds.

The Bucs have a little more to play for, as a win assures them of a first-round matchup with the NFC East champ, while a Week 17 loss could lead to a game against the Saints or Seahawks next weekend. That sounds pretty significant to me, but we already saw Bruce Arians remove Tom Brady at halftime last week, so don't be too surprised if key players are removed early or don't handle their typical workloads.

In terms of the non-playoff teams, it's a little tougher to figure things out. They won't usually bench their starters, but it is fairly common in the season finale to give backups more playing time than usual. 

One team I'm a little wary of is Atlanta, who could still draft as early as third overall or as late as ninth. I don't think the Falcons will bench healthy starters, but they could be more cautious than usual when it comes to managing injuries, and they might consider an early hook for the likes of Matt Ryan and Calvin Ridley

Really, it works out best for everyone involved if the Bucs beat the Falcons this Sunday. But that doesn't necessarily mean it will play out that way, as players and coaches for the Falcons presumably care about reputation more than they care about draft position for a team they may never work for again after Sunday.

Figuring all this stuff out is a pain in the butt, which is why most fantasy leagues wrap up with Week 16. Keep in mind that Exploiting the Matchups is posted on Thursdays, so a lot could change by the time we get to kickoff Sunday.

Before we get into specific players to upgrade or downgrade, here are some of my favorite tools for analyzing matchups:

Note: Discussion below mostly is limited to players that are being started in less than 80 percent of lineups on Yahoo. There are plenty of other players with good or bad matchups, but we'll focus our energy on the guys most likely to be involved in difficult start/sit decisions. Unless otherwise noted, references to 'fantasy points' are based on scoring with 25/10 yardage, 4/6 TDs and 0.5 PPR, a.k.a. standard settings on Yahoo and FanDuel.

Upgrade 👍

Quarterback

This matchup doesn't look great on paper — especially with Keenan Allen (hamstring) likely out again — but it should work out in Herbert's favor thanks to the lack of playoff implications for Kansas City. The last time this happened under Andy Reid was Week 17 of 2017, best remembered as Patrick Mahomes' first NFL start. In addition to Alex Smith, the Chiefs rested a group of key veterans that included LB Derrick Johnson, DE Justin Houston and TE Travis Kelce. This time around, Chris Jones and Tyrann Mathieu are among the top candidates to sit, while a number of other starters could be removed early.

  

Running Back

The 21-year-old will finish out his debut campaign against a Vikings team that dropped to 27th in run-defense DVOA (0.2%) and 28th in rushing yards allowed (134.8 per game) after getting humiliated by Alvin Kamara in Week 16. A matchup with the Lions should be more competitive, but it's still a nice setup for Swift, who has played more than half the offensive snaps in his last four games. In that span, he's averaged 12 carries for 54.3 yards and 4.3 catches for 33.5 yards, not to mention a quartet of touchdowns. The matchup is good enough that Swift can be started with confidence even if QB Matthew Stafford (ankle) doesn't play.

Hunt took just six, seven and four carries the past three weeks, after getting 10 or more in each of his first 12 games this season. Touchdowns and receiving production have kept him afloat from a fantasy perspective, and he should see at least a little more rushing volume this week, as the Browns are favored by 9.5 points with the Steelers expected to rest starters. Maybe we'll still see guys like T.J. Watt and Cameron Heyward early in the game, but if Ben Roethlisberger isn't playing at all, it's a good bet the team's defensive stars won't be handling full workloads. Hunt could run wild in the second half, which is when he's done most of his damage — 61 percent of his fantasy points — this year.

  

Wide Receiver

While top cornerback James Bradberry continues to play at a high level, the Giants secondary is otherwise vulnerable, with PFF grading Isaac Yiadom at No. 81 and Darnay Holmes at No. 110 out of 126 qualified cornerbacks. Bradberry shadowed Amari Cooper and helped limit him to 23 receiving yards in the first matchup between these teams, while Lamb led the Cowboys with 124 yards, and Gallup finished with 73 after a late surge once Andy Dalton replaced an injured Dak Prescott. The target distribution for Dalton has been pretty flat, with Cooper (56) barely seeing more looks than Lamb (55) and Gallup (52).

Tennessee has the worst defense of any probable playoff team, ranking 29th in DVOA (11.1%), 23rd in points allowed (26.7 per game) and 21st in opponent NY/A (6.7). Only the Lions have allowed more fantasy points to wide receivers, and the past month has been especially brutal, with the Titans giving up big games to the likes of Rashard Higgins (6-95-1), Donovan Peoples-Jones (2-92-1) and Keelan Cole (7-67-1), They've also been torched by No. 1 receivers over the past month, with Davante Adams, Marvin Jones and Jarvis Landry combining for 29 catches, 316 yards and five TDs on 34 targets.

  

Tight End

With Kyle Rudolph (foot) missing another game, Smith figures to play more than 80 percent of offensive snaps for a third straight week. The 22-year-old isn't likely to match his nine targets from the Week 16 loss to New Orleans, but he should get at least a handful of opportunities against arguably the worst defense in the NFL. Dalvin Cook's absence could lead to the long-awaited Mattison breakout game, or it could mean more targets for Smith, Justin Jefferson and Adam Thielen.

      

Downgrade 👎

Quarterback

A lot has changed since Nov. 1 when Wilson picked the Niners defense apart for a quartet of touchdowns. That was his sixth game in 2020 with 25 or more fantasy points, a mark he hasn't reached since the aforementioned Week 8 contest. Now closing out his regular season against a defense that's given up the sixth-fewest points to quarterbacks, Wilson may still be a top-10 option at his position, but he isn't in my top five.

  

Running Back

Conner won't necessarily be rested, but we do know he'll be lining up next to Mason Rudolph instead of Ben Roethlisberger, and there's a good chance some of the Pittsburgh starters who play will get pulled before the fourth quarter. Even if Snell or Anthony McFarland does end up with a bunch of carries, they could be getting them in a toothless offense with a bunch of other backups facing Cleveland's starters.

Bernard put up big numbers the past two weeks, but only after finishing with single-digit fantasy points in five consecutive games, so he's still averaging just 67.2 combined yards in nine starts this year. Samaje Perine got just three fewer carries than Bernard in a close game last week, and the Bengals aren't likely to sustain their recent ground success against a Baltimore defense that ranks eighth in DVOA against the run (-20.6%), 15th in opponent YPC (4.4) and ninth in rushing yards allowed (106.2 per game). While the likes of Tennessee and Cleveland have been able to run on the Ravens this year, lesser rushing attacks have routinely been shut down.

  

Wide Receiver

Crowder had a huge game last week and seems perpetually underrated, but that doesn't make him a good play for Week 17 against the Patriots. He'll primarily work the slot against Patriots cornerback Jonathan Jones, who has allowed just 6.8 YPT while grading out as PFF's No. 13 cornerback. Crowder did score a TD in the first matchup between these teams, but he saw a season-low two targets. He also struggled against the Patriots last year, catching six of 10 targets for 51 yards in two games.

Chark has lined up wide left on 52 percent of his snaps this year, compared to 29 percent wide right and 19 percent in the slot (per PFF). That gives him a primary matchup with Colts CB Xavier Rhodes, who has allowed just 6.5 YPT and 0.86 yards per cover snap in his age-30 rebound season. Chark did score one of his five TDs this season in the first matchup with Indianapolis, but he finished that Week 1 contest with only three targets and 25 yards.

  

Tight End

Cooper Kupp's likely absence increases the target share projection for everyone else in the Rams offense, but that isn't enough to make up for the loss of Jared Goff (thumb). Higbee is still in a timeshare with Gerald Everett, and his dependence on touchdowns becomes even more worrisome when the Rams are starting John Wolford instead of Goff.

     

Streaming Picks

For Shallow Leagues (40-69 percent rostered)

QB Kirk Cousins at DET

QB Matthew Stafford vs. MIN

RB Jeff Wilson vs. SEA

RB Zack Moss vs. MIA

RB Latavius Murray at CAR

WR Curtis Samuel vs. NO

WR Nelson Agholor at DEN

WR Mike Williams at KC

WR Michael Gallup at NYG

WR Sterling Shepard vs. DAL

TE Jonnu Smith at HOU

K Rodrigo Blankenship vs. JAX

D/ST Seattle Seahawks at SF

   

For Medium-depth Leagues (10-39 percent rostered)

QB Derek Carr at DEN

RB Alexander Mattison at DET

RB Malcolm Brown vs. ARZ

WR Mecole Hardman vs. LAC

WR Russell Gage at TB

WR Jakobi Meyers vs. NYJ

TE Irv Smith at DET

K Dan Bailey at DET

D/ST Philadelphia Eagles vs. WAS

   

For Deep Leagues (under 10 percent rostered)

QB Alex Smith at PHI

RB Dare Ogunbowale at IND

RB Darwin Thompson vs. LAC

WR Kendrick Bourne vs. SEA

WR Josh Reynolds vs. ARZ

WR James Washington at CLE

TE Jordan Akins vs. TEN

K Cody Parkey vs. PIT

D/ST New York Jets at NE

   

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jerry Donabedian
Jerry was a 2018 finalist for the FSWA's Player Notes Writer of the Year and DFS Writer of the Year awards. A Baltimore native, Jerry roots for the Ravens and watches "The Wire" in his spare time.
NFL Expert Picks: Christmas Special - Chiefs vs. Steelers; Ravens vs. Texans
NFL Expert Picks: Christmas Special - Chiefs vs. Steelers; Ravens vs. Texans
Survivor: Week 17 Strategy & Picks
Survivor: Week 17 Strategy & Picks
NFL DFS Breakdown: Christmas Matchups
NFL DFS Breakdown: Christmas Matchups
NFL Game Previews: Week 17 Christmas Matchups
NFL Game Previews: Week 17 Christmas Matchups