Weekly Pitcher Rankings: Is the Worst Yet to Come?

Weekly Pitcher Rankings: Is the Worst Yet to Come?

This article is part of our Weekly Pitcher Rankings series.

MLB, along with some reporters, broadcasters and Bryan Cranston are all taking victory laps. The problem is they're premature. Sure, games are shorter without disrupting too much on the field, though Alek Manoah and maybe Sandy Alcantara may beg to differ.

The caveat is we've yet to see what happens when the temperature and innings both rise. Will the pitch clock affect the quality of pitching? Will more injuries occur?

Who knows, but my more than ample gut says yes, in a resounding manner. I suspect ERA will continue to climb. 

As for this week, the focus will be on Emmet Sheehan. His upcoming schedule isn't ideal, but he's in a great spot, with only Michael Grove in his way.

The weekend series between the Cubs and Cardinals will be contested in London Stadium. In 2019, the Red Sox and Yankees competed in the first London Series, with the Yankees sweeping by scores of 17-13 and 12-8, strongly suggesting the venue is very hitter friendly. The Sunday night update will reflect the estimated park effect.

Especially with some sketchy weather for the rest of the week, these are subject to change. Please refer to the Probable Pitchers grid for scheduling question. As usual, hit me up with rankings concerns below.

UPDATED: Monday June 19, 2:15 AM ET

Week of June 19 - 25

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPCommentsMIX12MIX15
1Gerrit ColeNYYSEA, TEXStrikeouts down, and benefiting from 81.4% LOB, but still solid 
2

MLB, along with some reporters, broadcasters and Bryan Cranston are all taking victory laps. The problem is they're premature. Sure, games are shorter without disrupting too much on the field, though Alek Manoah and maybe Sandy Alcantara may beg to differ.

The caveat is we've yet to see what happens when the temperature and innings both rise. Will the pitch clock affect the quality of pitching? Will more injuries occur?

Who knows, but my more than ample gut says yes, in a resounding manner. I suspect ERA will continue to climb. 

As for this week, the focus will be on Emmet Sheehan. His upcoming schedule isn't ideal, but he's in a great spot, with only Michael Grove in his way.

The weekend series between the Cubs and Cardinals will be contested in London Stadium. In 2019, the Red Sox and Yankees competed in the first London Series, with the Yankees sweeping by scores of 17-13 and 12-8, strongly suggesting the venue is very hitter friendly. The Sunday night update will reflect the estimated park effect.

Especially with some sketchy weather for the rest of the week, these are subject to change. Please refer to the Probable Pitchers grid for scheduling question. As usual, hit me up with rankings concerns below.

UPDATED: Monday June 19, 2:15 AM ET

Week of June 19 - 25

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPCommentsMIX12MIX15
1Gerrit ColeNYYSEA, TEXStrikeouts down, and benefiting from 81.4% LOB, but still solid 
2Tyler GlasnowTBBAL, KCWalks up, but should get better  
3Spencer StriderATL@PHI, @CIN6 HR alllowed over last 15 IP  
4James PaxtonBOS@MIN, @CWS   
5Jose BerriosTOR@MIA, OAKPedestrian K-rate only concern  
6Shane McClanahanTBKC   
7Corbin BurnesMILARI, @CLEBar is high when 3.44 ERA is disappointing  
8Pablo LopezMINBOS, @DETBack on track  
9Merrill KellyARI@MIL, @SF   
10Zach EflinTBKC   
11Zac GallenARI@MIL   
12Zack WheelerPHINYM   
13Bailey OberMINBOS, @DET   
14Kevin GausmanTOR@MIA   
15Framber ValdezHOUNYM   
16Michael WachaSD@SF, WAS23.3% K-rate thrid best of career  
17Jon GrayTEX@NYY   
18Luis CastilloSEA@NYY   
19Michael LorenzenDETKC, MIN   
20Shohei OhtaniLAALAD   
21Chris BassittTOROAK   
22Cristian JavierHOUNYM   
23Blake SnellSD@SF   
24Garrett WhitlockBOS@MIN   
25Nathan EovaldiTEX@CWS   
26Clayton KershawLAD@LAA   
27Joe RyanMINBOS   
28Andrew AbbottCINCOL12 K to 9 BB in 17.2 IP -- danger lies ahead  
29Mitch KellerPIT@MIAGood spot to emerge from rut  
30Tyler WellsBAL@TBGraduatred from streamer to every week status  
31Joe MusgroveSDWASReally? Against Detroit? After I pimped you in my Rival.com lineup?
32Jesus LuzardoMIAPIT   
33Marcus StromanCHC@PIT3.63 xFIP says regression coming  
34Logan WebbSFARI   
35Aaron CivaleCLEOAK, MIL   
36Yu DarvishSD@SF   
37Domingo GermanNYYSEA   
38Shane BieberCLEMIL   
39Yonny ChirinosTBKCPlaying the role of Ryan Yarbrough, circa 2018-202017% 
40George KirbySEA@NYY, @BAL   
41Max ScherzerNYM@HOU, @PHI   
42Eury PerezMIATOR, PITPitching like he doesn't want to go back to riding buses 
43Hunter BrownHOUNYM, @LAD   
44Bobby MillerLADHOU   
45Ranger SuarezPHIATL, NYMBack on track, .90 ERA with 1.05 WHIP over last 20 IP, with 18 K 
46Aaron NolaPHIATL   
47Andrew HeaneyTEX@CWS, @NYY   
48Kyle GibsonBALSEA   
49Tony GonsolinLADHOU   
50Brayan BelloBOS@CWS   
51Dylan CeaseCWSTEX   
52Justin VerlanderNYM@HOU   
53Charlie MortonATL@CIN   
54Emmet SheehanLADHOUSimilar profile as Bryce Miller, should succeed in a like manner0%0%
55Anthony DeSclafaniSFSD, ARI   
56Reese OlsonDETKC, MIN 49% 
57Freddy PeraltaMIL@CLE   
58Sandy AlcantaraMIATORSpeculating, but maybe hurt by the pitch clock?  
59Kyle BradishBAL@TB   
60Kyle HendricksCHC@PIT 26% 
61Matthew BoydDETKC 13% 
62Kutter CrawfordBOS@MIN, @CWS 42% 
63Johan OviedoPITCHC, @MIA   
64Tanner BibeeCLEMIL   
65Sonny GrayMINBOS   
66Yusei KikuchiTOR@MIA, OAK   
67MacKenzie GoreWASSTL, @SD   
68Lucas GiolitoCWSBOS   
69Seth LugoSD@SF, WAS 25% 
70Brady SingerKC@DETShowing signs of returning to form, no excuse in this matchup 
71Braxton GarrettMIAPIT   
72Dane DunningTEX@NYY   
73Jordan MontgomerySTL@WAS   
74JP SearsOAK@CLE   
75Mix 12 Reliever     
76Jordan LylesKC@DET, @TB 0%0%
77Logan GilbertSEA@BAL   
78AJ Smith-ShawverATL@PHI   
79Logan AllenCLEOAK   
80Michael KopechCWSTEX   
81Wade MileyMIL@CLE 8%26%
82Jack FlahertySTL@WAS, CHCSecond game is in London  
83Bryce MillerSEA@BAL   
84Zack GreinkeKC@TB 9% 
85Mix 15 Reliever     
86Randy VasquezNYYSEA 0%0%
87Alex WoodSFSD 12% 
88Hunter GreeneCINATL   
89Bryce ElderATL@PHI   
90Hunter GaddisCLEOAK 1%2%
91Dean KremerBALSEA 23% 
92Sean ManaeaSFSD 7% 
93Taijuan WalkerPHIATL   
94Joey WentzDETMIN 0%0%
95Louie VarlandMIN@DET   
96Cristopher SanchezPHINYM 0%0%
97Luis SeverinoNYYTEX   
98Kyle FreelandCOL@CIN 12%47%
99Martin PerezTEX@CWS   
100Taj BradleyTBBAL   
101Miles MikolasSTL@WAS   
102Cole IrvinBALSEA 1%17%
103Corey KluberBOS@MIN 2%4%
104Reid DetmersLAALAD   
105Rich HillPITCHC 10% 
106Kodai SengaNYM@PHI   
107Drew SmylyCHC@PIT   
108Ben LivelyCINCOL 44% 
109Josiah GrayWASSTL, @SD   
110Noah DavisCOL@CIN 0%0%
111Patrick SandovalLAA@COL   
112Bryan WooSEA@NYY   
113Luis OrtizPIT@MIA 9% 
114Hogan HarrisOAK@TOR 0%4%
115Justin SteeleCHC@STLWorking in the London Series  
116Jared ShusterATL@CIN   
117Osvaldo BidoPITCHC, @MIA 0%0%
118Colin ReaMILARI 4% 
119Lance LynnCWSBOS   
120Daniel LynchKC@DET, @TB 4% 
121Brandon WilliamsonCINCOL, ATL 4%17%
122Griffin CanningLAA@COL   
123Tyler AndersonLAA@COL 20% 
124Ryne NelsonARI@MIL, @SF 3% 
125Clarke SchmidtNYYTEX   
126Tommy HenryARI@WAS 20% 
127Trevor WilliamsWASSTL 0%17%
128Connor SeaboldCOLLAA 0%0%
129Jakob JunisSFSD, ARI 0%0%
130Michael GroveLAD@LAA 7% 
131Austin GomberCOL@CIN, LAA 0%0%
132Paul BlackburnOAK@CLE 1%19%
133J.P. FranceHOU@LAD   
134Jesse ScholtensCWSTEX, BOS 0%0%
135Jake IrvinWASARI 0%2%
136Zach DaviesARI@SF 3%19%
137Luis MedinaOAK@CLE, @TOR 0%4%
138Chase AndersonCOLLAA 1%9%
139Julio TeheranMILARI 28% 
140Jonathan HeasleyKC@TB 0%0%
141Jameson TaillonCHC@STLWorking in the London Series  
142Tylor MegillNYM@HOU 29%42%
143Patrick CorbinWAS@SD 2%6%
144Bryan HoeingMIATOR, PIT 0%0%
145Carlos CarrascoNYM@PHI 22% 
146Adam WainwrightSTLCHCWorking in the London Series9%32%
147James KaprielianOAK@TOR 0%4%
148Luke WeaverCINATL 0%49%
149Ronel BlancoHOU@LAD 0%28%

American League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Gerrit ColeNYYSEA, TEXStrikeouts down, and benefiting from 81.4% LOB, but still solid
2Tyler GlasnowTBBAL, KCWalks up, but should get better
3James PaxtonBOS@MIN, @CWS
4Jose BerriosTOR@MIA, OAKPedestrian K-rate only concern
5Shane McClanahanTBKC 
6Pablo LopezMINBOS, @DETBack on track
7Zach EflinTBKC 
8Bailey OberMINBOS, @DET 
9Kevin GausmanTOR@MIA 
10Framber ValdezHOUNYM 
11Jon GrayTEX@NYY 
12Luis CastilloSEA@NYY 
13Michael LorenzenDETKC, MIN 
14Shohei OhtaniLAALAD 
15Chris BassittTOROAK 
16Cristian JavierHOUNYM 
17Garrett WhitlockBOS@MIN 
18Nathan EovaldiTEX@CWS 
19Joe RyanMINBOS 
20Tyler WellsBAL@TBGraduatred from streamer to every week status
21Aaron CivaleCLEOAK, MIL 
22Domingo GermanNYYSEA 
23Shane BieberCLEMIL 
24Yonny ChirinosTBKCPlaying the role of Ryan Yarbrough, circa 2018-2020
25George KirbySEA@NYY, @BAL 
26Hunter BrownHOUNYM, @LAD 
27Andrew HeaneyTEX@CWS, @NYY
28Kyle GibsonBALSEA 
29Brayan BelloBOS@CWS 
30Dylan CeaseCWSTEX 
31Reese OlsonDETKC, MIN 
32Kyle BradishBAL@TB 
33Matthew BoydDETKC 
34Kutter CrawfordBOS@MIN, @CWS
35Tanner BibeeCLEMIL 
36Sonny GrayMINBOS 
37Yusei KikuchiTOR@MIA, OAK 
38Lucas GiolitoCWSBOS 
39Brady SingerKC@DETShowing signs of returning to form, no excuse in this matchup
40Dane DunningTEX@NYY 
41JP SearsOAK@CLE 
42Jordan LylesKC@DET, @TB 
43Logan GilbertSEA@BAL 
44Logan AllenCLEOAK 
45Michael KopechCWSTEX 
46Bryce MillerSEA@BAL 
47Zack GreinkeKC@TB 
48Randy VasquezNYYSEA 
49Hunter GaddisCLEOAK 
50Dean KremerBALSEA 
51Joey WentzDETMIN 
52Louie VarlandMIN@DET 
53Luis SeverinoNYYTEX 
54Martin PerezTEX@CWS 
55Taj BradleyTBBAL 
56AL Reliever   
57Cole IrvinBALSEA 
58Corey KluberBOS@MIN 
59Reid DetmersLAALAD 
60Patrick SandovalLAA@COL 
61Bryan WooSEA@NYY 
62Hogan HarrisOAK@TOR 
63Lance LynnCWSBOS 
64Daniel LynchKC@DET, @TB 
65Griffin CanningLAA@COL 
66Tyler AndersonLAA@COL 
67Clarke SchmidtNYYTEX 
68Paul BlackburnOAK@CLE 
69J.P. FranceHOU@LAD 
70Jesse ScholtensCWSTEX, BOS 
71Luis MedinaOAK@CLE, @TOR 
72Jonathan HeasleyKC@TB 
73James KaprielianOAK@TOR 
74Ronel BlancoHOU@LAD 

National League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Spencer StriderATL@PHI, @CIN6 HR alllowed over last 15 IP
2Corbin BurnesMILARI, @CLEBar is high when 3.44 ERA is disappointing
3Merrill KellyARI@MIL, @SF 
4Zac GallenARI@MIL 
5Zack WheelerPHINYM 
6Michael WachaSD@SF, WAS23.3% K-rate thrid best of career
7Blake SnellSD@SF 
8Clayton KershawLAD@LAA 
9Andrew AbbottCINCOL12 K to 9 BB in 17.2 IP -- danger lies ahead
10Mitch KellerPIT@MIAGood spot to emerge from rut
11Joe MusgroveSDWASReally? Against Detroit? After I pimped you in my Rival.com lineup?
12Jesus LuzardoMIAPIT 
13Marcus StromanCHC@PIT3.63 xFIP says regression coming
14Logan WebbSFARI 
15Yu DarvishSD@SF 
16Max ScherzerNYM@HOU, @PHI 
17Eury PerezMIATOR, PITPitching like he doesn't want to go back to riding buses
18Bobby MillerLADHOU 
19Ranger SuarezPHIATL, NYMBack on track, .90 ERA with 1.05 WHIP over last 20 IP, with 18 K
20Aaron NolaPHIATL 
21Tony GonsolinLADHOU 
22Justin VerlanderNYM@HOU 
23Charlie MortonATL@CIN 
24Emmet SheehanLADHOUSimilar profile as Bryce Miller, should succeed in a like manner
25Anthony DeSclafaniSFSD, ARI 
26Freddy PeraltaMIL@CLE 
27Sandy AlcantaraMIATORSpeculating, but maybe hurt by the pitch clock?
28Kyle HendricksCHC@PIT 
29Johan OviedoPITCHC, @MIA 
30MacKenzie GoreWASSTL, @SD 
31Seth LugoSD@SF, WAS 
32Braxton GarrettMIAPIT 
33Jordan MontgomerySTL@WAS 
34AJ Smith-ShawverATL@PHI 
35Wade MileyMIL@CLE 
36Jack FlahertySTL@WAS, CHCSecond game is in London
37Alex WoodSFSD 
38Hunter GreeneCINATL 
39Bryce ElderATL@PHI 
40Sean ManaeaSFSD 
41Taijuan WalkerPHIATL 
42Cristopher SanchezPHINYM 
43Kyle FreelandCOL@CIN 
44NL Reliever   
45Miles MikolasSTL@WAS 
46Rich HillPITCHC 
47Kodai SengaNYM@PHI 
48Drew SmylyCHC@PIT 
49Ben LivelyCINCOL 
50Josiah GrayWASSTL, @SD 
51Noah DavisCOL@CIN 
52Luis OrtizPIT@MIA 
53Justin SteeleCHC@STLWorking in the London Series
54Jared ShusterATL@CIN 
55Osvaldo BidoPITCHC, @MIA 
56Colin ReaMILARI 
57Brandon WilliamsonCINCOL, ATL 
58Ryne NelsonARI@MIL, @SF 
59Tommy HenryARI@WAS 
60Trevor WilliamsWASSTL 
61Connor SeaboldCOLLAA 
62Jakob JunisSFSD, ARI 
63Michael GroveLAD@LAA 
64Austin GomberCOL@CIN, LAA 
65Jake IrvinWASARI 
66Zach DaviesARI@SF 
67Chase AndersonCOLLAA 
68Julio TeheranMILARI 
69Jameson TaillonCHC@STLWorking in the London Series
70Tylor MegillNYM@HOU 
71Patrick CorbinWAS@SD 
72Bryan HoeingMIATOR, PIT 
73Carlos CarrascoNYM@PHI 
74Adam WainwrightSTLCHCWorking in the London Series
75Luke WeaverCINATL 

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Todd Zola
Todd has been writing about fantasy baseball since 1997. He won NL Tout Wars and Mixed LABR in 2016 as well as a multi-time league winner in the National Fantasy Baseball Championship. Todd is now setting his sights even higher: The Rotowire Staff League. Lord Zola, as he's known in the industry, won the 2013 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Article of the Year award and was named the 2017 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Writer of the Year. Todd is a five-time FSWA awards finalist.
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers
Collette Calls: Thinking About Pitchers Returning From Injuries
Collette Calls: Thinking About Pitchers Returning From Injuries
MLB DFS Picks: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Wednesday, October 30
MLB DFS Picks: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Wednesday, October 30