RotoWire Roundtable: March Consolidated Top 350

Written by

Updated on March 29, 2013 6:43PM EST

The RotoWire Roundtable: March Consolidated Top 350

Welcome to the second edition of the RotoWire Roundtable. Since our February update, there have been significant injury updates, closer battles and even a few prospects that look like they'll break camp with their teams. The goal of the March update is to help you refine your draft day strategy. Below you will see our rankers' consolidated top-350 players.

These rankings were assembled for 12-team, 5x5 mixed leagues that start two catchers per team (thus there is a positional scarcity component added for catchers). Our five esteemed rankers are: Jeff Erickson, Derek VanRiper, Michael Rusignola, Kevin Payne and Jason Collette. The rankings were provided completely blinded - none of the rankers saw any of the other rankings before the publication of this article. For more background on how to use these rankings, see the introduction to last month's update.

Upgrades since February

First, we'll go through a couple of players who have been upgraded since our February update.

The RotoWire Roundtable: March Consolidated Top 350

First, we'll go through a couple of players who have been upgraded since our February update.

- Aroldis Chapman (CL) - March Rank: 65; FebruaryRank: 114.
- Adam Eaton (OF) - March Rank: 212; FebruaryRank: 345.
- Jose Reyes (SS) - March Rank: 24; FebruaryRank: 39.
- Oscar Taveras (OF) - March Rank: 279; FebruaryRank: NR.
- Jedd Gyorko (2B) - March Rank: 223; FebruaryRank: 343.
- Matt Carpenter (3B)- March Rank: 306; FebruaryRank: NR.
- Carlos Gomez (OF)- March Rank: 198; FebruaryRank: 285.
- Nolan Arenado (3B) - March Rank: 312; FebruaryRank: NR.
- Mat Latos (SP) - March Rank: 101; FebruaryRank: 137.
- Marco Estrada (SP)- March Rank: 219; FebruaryRank: 297.

Now that Aroldis Chapman has been named the closer in Cincinnati, he goes from intriguing starter to dominating closer. Some might even make the case for taking Chapman over Craig Kimbrel. Chapman's value gets a huge bump from the Reds leaving him where he belongs. Adam Eaton moved up because of his strong spring performance and because he is likely the best defensive outfielder the Snakes have. That translates to playing time. The injury prevents him from trending even higher, as the speed and some power is there. Shortstop is not deep this season, which is part of the reason we're seeing a bump with Jose Reyes. When Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion headed north of the border, they suddenly gained power (ah-hem, stealing signs). Any kind of power surge in addition to an elite number of steals makes him incredibly valuable (don't forget, Reyes has hit 19 in a season). Think of him as a potential Carl Crawford in his best years but qualifying at SS.

Oscar Taveras tore the cover off the ball this spring, and with Carlos Beltran adding a toe injury to his chronic knee trouble, it seems as though Taveras's call-up is closer than we previously thought. The Cards won't bring him up without playing him every day, which makes him a more valuable prospect-type to own than most. Jedd Gyorko looks to have a clear path now at third base to begin the season without Chase Headley and Logan Forsythe, and as the regular second baseman thereafter. The thin nature of second base makes him a great late target, as he possesses more upside than the typical keystone options available that late. The best argument I've heard in favor of Carlos Gomez is "What is the difference between Gomez and B.J. Upton other than 150 ADP spots?" More playing time is in store for Gomez this year too with the new contract. Even though he was sent down by the Rockies on Thursday, Nolan Arenado looks like he's much closer to breaking through this season. Chris Nelson is a nice utility type, but Arenado may only have four-to-six weeks in the minors to delay his service time before taking over a spot near the middle of the lineup in the best hitter environment in the league.

Downgrades since February

Here are the players who have seen their ranking fall since February.

- Curtis Granderson (OF) - March Rank: 89; FebruaryRank: 22.
- Mark Teixeira (1B) - March Rank: 172; FebruaryRank: 54.
- Hanley Ramirez (SS) - March Rank: 94; FebruaryRank: 41.
- Chase Headley (3B) - March Rank: 100; FebruaryRank: 47.
- Danny Espinosa (2B) - March Rank: 164; FebruaryRank: 95.
- Roy Halladay (SP) - March Rank: 103; FebruaryRank: 64.
- Scott Baker (SP) - March Rank: 347; FebruaryRank: 227.
- Jonathan Broxton (SP) - March Rank: 343; FebruaryRank: 226.
- Brett Lawrie (3B) - March Rank: 80; FebruaryRank: 58.
- David Ortiz (DH) - March Rank: 158; FebruaryRank: 118.

Targeting Curtis Granderson depends on your league's DL rules, but in the RotoWire Staff League, for example, we have no spots to stash injured players. Granderson should be productive once he's ready to return, but our heavy downgrade is more for the lack of flexibility owning him provides than anything else. If you play in a shallow mixed league with several or unlimited DL spots, a more aggressive draft slot is acceptable because the replacement level from the waiver wire is substantially higher. The concern with Hanley Ramirez is that even after he returns, his power may be sapped by the injury. He's already a liability of sorts in the batting average category, and the added risk of lackluster production in an area that he needs to deliver in order to return steady value is problematic.

Chase Headley's injury, something that is en vogue for his position these days, hurts his value. People already had concerns about a power regression, but losing time due to injury only compounds the issue. Each time Roy Halladay pitches, his top fastball velocity gets closer to mine (and I'm not much of an athlete). Halladay looks shaky and after many seasons of being a stud, he is showing dud warning signs this spring. Side issues, like what Brett Lawrie is suffering, tend to linger. Pitchers adjusted to Lawrie last season and the question is now: can Lawrie adjust to them? Third base is a crapshoot; there can be a ton of injuries. At this point in one-year leagues, Lawrie vs. Will Middlebrooks is fairly close.

And on with...

The List

Rank	Full Name	Pos	Jeff	DVR	Michael	Kevin	Jason	Median
1	Miguel Cabrera	3B	1	1	2	2	2	2
2	Ryan Braun	OF	2	2	1	3	1	2
3	Mike Trout	OF	3	7	3	1	3	3
4	Matt Kemp	OF	6	3	4	4	4	4
5	Andrew McCutchen	OF	5	9	5	9	5	5
6	Robinson Cano	2B	4	6	7	6	6	6
7	Carlos Gonzalez	OF	7	5	9	8	8	8
8	Albert Pujols	1B	9	13	8	5	7	8
9	Joey Votto	1B	8	4	11	15	9	9
10	Giancarlo Stanton	OF	11	10	18	7	10	10
11	Jose Bautista	OF	10	11	10	11	12	11
12	Prince Fielder	1B	13	8	15	10	11	11
13	Justin Upton	OF	12	14	12	12	20	12
14	Clayton Kershaw	SP	14	17	6	20	14	14
15	Troy Tulowitzki	SS	15	15	22	13	18	15
16	Bryce Harper	OF	16	16	17	14	15	16
17	Justin Verlander	SP	17	18	16	16	19	17
18	Buster Posey	C	20	22	13	18	13	18
19	Adrian Beltre	3B	18	21	14	21	16	18
20	Stephen Strasburg	SP	19	12	32	17	29	19
21	Josh Hamilton	OF	22	27	23	19	17	22
22	Edwin Encarnacion	1B	21	29	33	22	21	22
23	Jason Heyward	OF	23	19	31	26	24	24
24	Jose Reyes	SS	26	24	20	24	61	24
25	Evan Longoria	3B	30	20	49	27	26	27
26	David Wright	3B	24	34	28	38	27	28
27	David Price	SP	28	23	35	28	43	28
28	Dustin Pedroia	2B	27	31	29	25	45	29
29	Jacoby Ellsbury	OF	25	30	26	33	42	30
30	Paul Goldschmidt	1B	32	28	30	45	30	30
31	Ian Kinsler	2B	31	38	47	23	33	33
32	Jay Bruce	OF	33	32	41	51	25	33
33	Adrian Gonzalez	1B	34	39	19	37	22	34
34	Cliff Lee	SP	29	44	24	35	35	35
35	Adam Jones	OF	35	41	21	40	31	35
36	B.J. Upton	OF	36	33	38	36	23	36
37	Starlin Castro	SS	39	40	37	30	36	37
38	Allen Craig	OF	37	46	25	55	28	37
39	Billy Butler	1B	40	37	34	52	32	37
40	Ryan Zimmerman	3B	38	26	42	42	37	38
41	Craig Kimbrel	CL	43	36	40	34	64	40
42	Cole Hamels	SP	41	43	36	39	46	41
43	Yadier Molina	C	42	64	44	65	34	44
44	Aramis Ramirez	3B	54	35	46	44	54	46
45	Freddie Freeman	1B	45	47	56	71	47	47
46	Felix Hernandez	SP	48	49	55	32	48	48
47	Carlos Santana	C	51	42	70	49	40	49
48	Yoenis Cespedes	OF	50	25	54	41	52	50
49	Matt Holliday	OF	44	50	48	50	57	50
50	Jason Kipnis	2B	53	62	50	46	41	50
51	Jered Weaver	SP	60	69	45	48	51	51
52	Joe Mauer	C	49	55	51	91	49	51
53	Matt Cain	SP	47	53	53	31	74	53
54	Alex Gordon	OF	58	51	43	108	53	53
55	Yu Darvish	SP	46	57	80	56	50	56
56	Madison Bumgarner	SP	56	56	59	59	76	59
57	Brandon Phillips	2B	52	72	57	61	77	61
58	Anthony Rizzo	1B	62	75	61	75	38	62
59	Melky Cabrera	OF	73	59	39	81	62	62
60	Miguel Montero	C	63	86	60	73	59	63
61	Wilin Rosario	C	64	88	69	60	63	64
62	Aaron Hill	2B	65	48	76	54	71	65
63	Matt Wieters	C	55	66	74	70	44	66
64	Gio Gonzalez	SP	66	90	64	53	83	66
65	Aroldis Chapman	CL	67	45	68	82	68	68
66	Michael Bourn	OF	68	104	52	87	60	68
67	Adam Wainwright	SP	57	54	77	69	70	69
68	Ben Zobrist	2B	69	60	85	43	87	69
69	Desmond Jennings	OF	71	87	73	62	73	73
70	Paul Konerko	1B	83	73	58	141	55	73
71	Chris Sale	SP	74	58	78	66	103	74
72	Kris Medlen	SP	72	84	27	85	75	75
73	Eric Hosmer	1B	61	76	67	80	80	76
74	Shin-Soo Choo	OF	76	68	71	105	81	76
75	CC Sabathia	SP	59	71	92	76	118	76
76	Jose Altuve	2B	77	63	66	79	93	77
77	Jonathan Papelbon	CL	86	77	101	72	66	77
78	Johnny Cueto	SP	70	78	75	77	108	77
79	Jimmy Rollins	SS	78	74	98	57	101	78
80	Brett Lawrie	3B	79	65	86	92	58	79
81	R.A. Dickey	SP	93	70	79	64	84	79
82	Austin Jackson	OF	80	67	63	83	90	80
83	Ike Davis	1B	81	52	95	96	78	81
84	James Shields	SP	90	82	62	98	69	82
85	Ryan Howard	1B	106	80	84	101	56	84
86	Alex Rios	OF	84	115	72	94	65	84
87	Mark Trumbo	OF	108	121	82	88	89	89
88	Max Scherzer	SP	89	92	143	58	107	92
89	Curtis Granderson	OF	85	160	102	68	94	94
90	Ian Desmond	SS	75	111	97	29	102	97
91	Asdrubal Cabrera	SS	94	97	109	74	182	97
92	Matt Moore	SP	107	83	190	67	98	98
93	Jordan Zimmermann	SP	88	79	100	99	104	99
94	Hanley Ramirez	SS	101	135	153	47	39	101
95	Adam LaRoche	1B	98	101	110	189	96	101
96	Carlos Beltran	OF	104	102	90	107	97	102
97	Yovani Gallardo	SP	102	91	147	90	130	102
98	Pablo Sandoval	3B	91	61	112	103	116	103
99	Torii Hunter	OF	130	103	94	204	92	103
100	Chase Headley	3B	100	136	104	78	136	104
101	Mat Latos	SP	95	81	139	104	141	104
102	Chris Davis	1B	110	106	88	114	82	106
103	Roy Halladay	SP	118	95	107	89	176	107
104	Nelson Cruz	OF	114	108	87	123	86	108
105	Elvis Andrus	SS	97	113	108	86	160	108
106	Josh Willingham	OF	109	159	81	122	67	109
107	Mariano Rivera	CL	92	89	116	110	110	110
108	Nick Swisher	OF	112	110	91	167	88	110
109	Fernando Rodney	CL	87	122	111	125	79	111
110	Angel Pagan	OF	111	131	65	173	91	111
111	Rafael Soriano	CL	121	105	194	113	105	113
112	Mike Napoli	C	82	126	83	115	128	115
113	Jesus Montero	C	115	125	103	130	72	115
114	Hunter Pence	OF	134	117	96	158	85	117
115	Ian Kennedy	SP	132	123	105	117	115	117
116	Brandon Morrow	SP	117	85	152	106	154	117
117	Jason Motte	CL	141	150	117	97	112	117
118	Norichika Aoki	OF	149	109	89	124	119	119
119	Kyle Seager	3B	113	158	119	165	117	119
120	Zack Greinke	SP	126	94	120	63	126	120
121	Shane Victorino	OF	120	129	106	112	120	120
122	Sergio Romo	CL	96	127	113	160	122	122
123	Rickie Weeks	2B	124	100	155	120	156	124
124	Jon Lester	SP	103	124	208	109	203	124
125	Victor Martinez	C	135	93	128	84	127	127
126	Salvador Perez	C	127	107	141	118	164	127
127	Cameron Maybin	OF	133	128	124	199	125	128
128	Justin Morneau	1B	129	98	99	144	167	129
129	Josh Reddick	OF	146	175	127	129	123	129
130	Kendrys Morales	1B	152	120	131	127	135	131
131	Martin Prado	OF	139	99	132	116	180	132
132	Carl Crawford	OF	178	116	187	100	133	133
133	J.J. Putz	CL	119	140	135	148	109	135
134	Dan Haren	SP	116	151	126	149	137	137
135	Alfonso Soriano	OF	137	191	114	196	99	137
136	Jayson Werth	OF	138	155	118	142	129	138
137	Jonathan Lucroy	C	136	118	150	145	139	139
138	Will Middlebrooks	3B	140	145	129	102	150	140
139	Mike Moustakas	3B	143	119	167	140	140	140
140	Pedro Alvarez	3B	128	143	189	175	138	143
141	Coco Crisp	OF	144	148	115	183	121	144
142	Alejandro De Aza	OF	151	147	93	203	131	147
143	Mike Morse	OF	147	245	121	126	169	147
144	Joe Nathan	CL	99	149	148	174	106	148
145	Jim Johnson	CL	148	192	172	137	145	148
146	Nick Markakis	OF	163	114	149	150	124	149
147	Chase Utley	2B	125	169	151	121	212	151
148	Josh Johnson	SP	153	152	163	157	152	153
149	Ryan Doumit	C	172	154	165	138	147	154
150	Howie Kendrick	2B	155	157	146	135	191	155
151	Andre Ethier	OF	162	156	123	151	166	156
152	Greg Holland	CL	123	177	156	180	134	156
153	Jeff Samardzija	SP	158	153	170	143	157	157
154	Tom Wilhelmsen	CL	122	195	158	168	113	158
155	Jon Niese	SP	105	181	159	198	153	159
156	Brian McCann	C	181	137	204	134	159	159
157	Derek Jeter	SS	206	142	145	159	183	159
158	David Ortiz	DH	197	162	160	156	114	160
159	C.J. Wilson	SP	145	132	184	161	161	161
160	John Axford	CL	142	164	226	171	100	164
161	Adam Dunn	1B	165	133	245	181	144	165
162	Brett Anderson	SP	160	166	168	166	216	166
163	Dayan Viciedo	OF	222	138	166	212	155	166
164	Danny Espinosa	2B	176	168	192	95	95	168
165	Joel Hanrahan	CL	166	231	229	164	168	168
166	Hiroki Kuroda	SP	131	193	144	169	170	169
167	Jake Peavy	SP	169	112	202	163	213	169
168	Doug Fister	SP	170	202	136	147	171	170
169	Neil Walker	2B	159	170	142	185	174	170
170	David Freese	3B	204	171	137	128	178	171
171	Alexi Ogando	SP	171	165	157	228	193	171
172	Mark Teixeira	1B	287	215	171	153	143	171
173	Ryan Ludwick	OF	177	172	138	240	132	172
174	Michael Cuddyer	OF	203	139	173	132	184	173
175	Dexter Fowler	OF	173	134	161	195	217	173
176	Jason Kubel	OF	215	173	169	211	165	173
177	Ryan Vogelsong	SP	157	295	162	218	173	173
178	Ben Revere	OF	186	205	122	152	175	175
179	J.P. Arencibia	C	156	176	219	227	146	176
180	Corey Hart	1B	211	161	176	119	274	176
181	Todd Frazier	3B	174	141	198	177	202	177
182	Grant Balfour	CL	198	178	164	191	148	178
183	Glen Perkins	CL	168	232	178	210	111	178
184	Tim Hudson	SP	150	264	134	254	179	179
185	Starling Marte	OF	180	208	130	213	158	180
186	Rafael Betancourt	CL	179	252	182	202	172	182
187	Alexei Ramirez	SS	167	221	183	178	192	183
188	Jarrod Parker	SP	183	180	214	179	200	183
189	Homer Bailey	SP	184	197	180	193	162	184
190	Dustin Ackley	2B	154	184	179	221	295	184
191	A.J. Pierzynski	C	182	218	185	184	187	185
192	Alcides Escobar	SS	190	183	186	133	222	186
193	Michael Saunders	OF	185	187	193	220	151	187
194	Chris Perez	CL	164	190	199	188	149	188
195	Mike Minor	SP	161	196	217	187	190	190
196	Brett Gardner	OF	192	130	222	139	242	192
197	Lorenzo Cain	OF	193	273	177	186	198	193
198	Carlos Gomez	OF	194	146	206	111	324	194
199	Erick Aybar	SS	191	244	195	162	218	195
200	Anibal Sanchez	SP	187	198	239	192	201	198
201	Addison Reed	CL	201	174	270	182	199	199
202	Matt Harvey	SP	188	266	203	131	239	203
203	Wade Miley	SP	195	296	197	206	205	205
204	Huston Street	CL	207	163	218	176	211	207
205	Ernesto Frieri	CL	209	269	188	207	194	207
206	Michael Young	3B	205	213	125	248	208	208
207	Jeremy Hellickson	SP	189	229	216	209	204	209
208	Carlos Quentin	OF	223	206	209	247	195	209
209	Tim Lincecum	SP	213	96	333	93	235	213
210	Ichiro Suzuki	OF	214	250	181	155	233	214
211	Steve Cishek	CL	208	253	220	217	186	217
212	Adam Eaton	OF	217	209	287	170		217
213	A.J. Burnett	SP	218	265	235	214	177	218
214	Dan Uggla	2B	175	219	224	136	294	219
215	J.J. Hardy	SS	238	222	211	208	219	219
216	Mark Reynolds	1B	199	220	213	283	271	220
217	Brandon League	CL	202	345	273	219	220	220
218	Brandon Moss	1B	221	277	133	298	163	221
219	Marco Estrada	SP	212	228	191	222	255	222
220	Juan Pierre	OF	228	211	175	226	223	223
221	Brandon Belt	1B	196	167	267	224	273	224
222	Manny Machado	3B	236	182	225	223	236	225
223	Jedd Gyorko	2B	253	200	210	225		225
224	Trevor Cahill	SP	226	179	244	245	207	226
225	Derek Holland	SP	227	203	242	241	221	227
226	Jason Grilli	CL	200	285	227	266	181	227
227	Kenley Jansen	STP	244	224	154	344	228	228
228	Alex Avila	C	219	201	248	233	230	230
229	Alex Cobb	SP	210	230	205	285	291	230
230	Lance Lynn	SP	231	194	243	146	240	231
231	Garrett Jones	1B	233	276	221	234	210	233
232	Russell Martin	C	234	233	290	239	214	234
233	Josh Beckett	SP	235	199	236	197	253	235
234	Kyle Lohse	SP	265	321	207	236	188	236
235	Wil Myers	OF	232	235	325	238	313	238
236	David Murphy	OF	239	274	196	256	225	239
237	Jean Segura	SS	241	271	237	232	250	241
238	Chris Carter	1B	240	144	279	279	243	243
239	Justin Ruggiano	OF	216	246	140	271	247	246
240	Jarrod Saltalamacchia	C	225	261	266	246	197	246
241	Hisashi Iwakuma	SP	247	332	174	278	209	247
242	Josh Rutledge	SS	252	293	230	154	248	248
243	Tyler Flowers	C	230	248	280	340	189	248
244	Brandon McCarthy	SP	266	226	228	249	270	249
245	Ryan Dempster	SP	249	324	309	230	234	249
246	Jed Lowrie	SS	294	207		242	249	249
247	Mike Fiers	SP	334	339	251	250	241	251
248	Matt Harrison	SP	224	286	254	235	261	254
249	Matt Garza	SP	271	217	281	201	256	256
250	Chris Young	OF	281	259	256	243	229	256
251	Carlos Ruiz	C	220	313	257	200	269	257
252	Matt Joyce	OF	245	257	275	280	245	257
253	Lance Berkman	1B	286	188	319	258	142	258
254	Michael Brantley	OF	251	275	200	315	259	259
255	Lucas Duda	OF	259	304	241	342	244	259
256	Justin Maxwell	OF	255	281	260	312	224	260
257	Jeff Francoeur	OF	260	308	238		251	260
258	Yonder Alonso	1B	261	185	286	261	298	261
259	Omar Infante	2B	301	234	262	259	297	262
260	Denard Span	OF	276	210	284	263	246	263
261	Wandy Rodriguez	SP	248	323	264	286	232	264
262	Phil Hughes	SP	264	263	295	262	327	264
263	Drew Stubbs	OF	278	258	292	253	267	267
264	Shaun Marcum	SP	267	309	232	293	264	267
265	Cody Ross	OF	343	214	306	267	263	267
266	Edwin Jackson	SP	237	268	271	282	215	268
267	Zack Cozart	SS	256	255	268	268	278	268
268	Marco Scutaro	2B	269	319	215	190	302	269
269	Everth Cabrera	SS	257	270	289	172	289	270
270	Emilio Bonifacio	OF	305	249	272	215	306	272
271	Kyuji Fujikawa	CL	306	299	240	274	227	274
272	Daniel Murphy	2B	274		249	244	315	274
273	Stephen Drew	SS	316	216	274	275	281	275
274	Delmon Young	OF	277		250	276	260	276
275	Kevin Youkilis	3B	246	290	277	205	280	277
276	Colby Rasmus	OF	283	278	308	255	272	278
277	Kelly Johnson	2B	254		278	321	238	278
278	Jurickson Profar	SS	279	239		260		279
279	Oscar Taveras	OF	280	237		281		281
280	A.J. Ellis	C	282	282	291	284	268	282
281	Casey Janssen	CL	250	284	314	194	329	284
282	Adam Lind	1B	285	254	296	297	277	285
283	Andy Pettitte	SP	275	287	283	288	320	287
284	Wei-Yin Chen	SP	263	331	288	320	275	288
285	Ricky Romero	SP	288	225		329	286	288
286	Jhonny Peralta	SS	292	294	258	296	283	292
287	Hyun-Jin Ryu	SP	273	340	322	294	288	294
288	Clay Buchholz	SP	262	288	346	300	296	296
289	Will Venable	OF	296	347	297	324	287	297
290	Welington Castillo	C	229	312	298		231	298
291	Bobby Parnell	CL	299	262	265	332	332	299
292	Chris Johnson	3B	284	327	299	322	292	299
293	Trevor Bauer	SP		300		299	293	300
294	John Jaso	C	242	325	318	302	276	302
295	Chris Iannetta	C	302	283		290	304	302
296	Hiroyuki Nakajima	SS	303	310	233		252	303
297	Tommy Milone	SP	270		328	257	303	303
298	Peter Bourjos	OF	293	212	312		310	310
299	Johan Santana	SP		279	331	310	301	310
300	Jon Jay	OF	340	311	307	270		311
301	Miguel Gonzalez	SP	311		282		311	311
302	Scott Feldman	SP	312	303			312	312
303	Billy Hamilton	SS	313	238		295		313
304	Yasmani Grandal	C	314	314	326	327	314	314
305	Tyler Colvin	OF	315	186		229	337	315
306	Matt Carpenter	3B	298	315	246	323		315
307	Jordan Pacheco	3B	327	316	212	345	284	316
308	Dillon Gee	SP		267		216	316	316
309	Chris Capuano	SP			261	316	237	316
310	Lonnie Chisenhall	3B	317	223	320	311	321	317
311	Ross Detwiler	SP	297	333	304		317	317
312	Nolan Arenado	3B	308	251		317		317
313	Justin Smoak	1B	243	318	323	272		318
314	Mike Olt	3B	318	240		343	257	318
315	Mitch Moreland	1B	319	189	317	330	322	319
316	Paul Maholm	SP	300		338	309	319	319
317	Josh Donaldson	3B	321		302		279	321
318	Chris Nelson	3B	322	317	305	339	325	322
319	Chris Tillman	SP	323	227	340	251	343	323
320	Carlos Pena	1B	309	326			308	326
321	Edinson Volquez	SP	320			326	323	326
322	Gordon Beckham	2B	258	328	339	292		328
323	Logan Morrison	OF	330	242		273	330	330
324	James McDonald	SP	272		335	331	266	331
325	Travis d'Arnaud	C	331	329		304	340	331
326	Al Alburquerque	CL	332		223		262	332
327	Cory Luebke	SP		336	231	334	328	334
328	Andrelton Simmons	SS	268		334	269		334
329	Wade Davis	SP	307	334	348		307	334
330	Gavin Floyd	SP	326		337		285	337
331	Ervin Santana	SP	339		327		265	339
332	Kurt Suzuki	C	289		341	346	282	341
333	David Hernandez	STP		341	253		331	341
334	Andy Dirks	OF	342		294	289	349	342
335	Vance Worley	SP		306	342		335	342
336	Travis Snider	OF		280	343	350	344	344
337	Chad Billingsley	SP		344	344		290	344
338	Trevor Plouffe	3B		302		231	346	346
339	Ryan Madson	STP	346	343	321			346
340	Mark Buehrle	SP		346		337	342	346
341	Yunel Escobar	SS	350	298	347	308		347
342	A.J. Griffin	SP		349	315	303		349
343	Jonathan Broxton	SP				237	185	387.5
344	Sean Marshall	STP			234		206	387.5
345	Jason Hammel	SP		204		287		387.5
346	Aaron Hicks	OF	295		201			387.5
347	Scott Baker	SP		307			196	387.5
348	Carlos Marmol	CL	291			265		387.5
349	Erasmo Ramirez	SP		305			254	387.5
350	Derek Norris	C	338				226	387.5

NR = Not Ranked
Abst = Abstained from Ranking

Players with the same median were ranked secondarily by their average ranking. Players who were not ranked were assigned a ranking of 387.5 (the midpoint between 351 and 424, the total number of ranked players) for the purpose of computing the median and average.