Top 200 Prospects: October Rankings

Top 200 Prospects: October Rankings

This article is part of our Top 200 Prospects series.

The following listing is our ranking of our Top Prospects. It includes some players that are currently in the major leagues, but with short tenures. Many of those players will probably be purged from the list as soon as we become more confident that they're not in danger of being sent back down to the minors.

Players who have exceeded rookie qualifications at the time of publication (130 at-bats, 50 innings) are not included.

1. We tilt more toward fantasy potential than MLB potential (and, yes, there is a difference)
2. We take positional history into play (please refer to last month's column for explanation)
3. We give those who have played in full-season leagues preference over players with only short-season league history and discount recent draftees that have not yet played in the minors.
4. We do not rank import players.
5. We do not consider college players prospects until they are signed with their major league organization and start producing in the minors.
6. We do not consider relievers top 100 prospects because nearly all of them need to fail as starting prospects first.
7. We do not rank anyone that has already hit the majors this year as I am assuming that someone in your league has grabbed them on the waiver wire.

ORGPOSSiegelRankCollettePOSORG
BALPDylan Bundy1Billy HamiltonOFCIN
TEXSSJurickson Profar2Jurickson ProfarSSTEX
KCOFWil Myers3Dylan BundyPBAL

The following listing is our ranking of our Top Prospects. It includes some players that are currently in the major leagues, but with short tenures. Many of those players will probably be purged from the list as soon as we become more confident that they're not in danger of being sent back down to the minors.

Players who have exceeded rookie qualifications at the time of publication (130 at-bats, 50 innings) are not included.

1. We tilt more toward fantasy potential than MLB potential (and, yes, there is a difference)
2. We take positional history into play (please refer to last month's column for explanation)
3. We give those who have played in full-season leagues preference over players with only short-season league history and discount recent draftees that have not yet played in the minors.
4. We do not rank import players.
5. We do not consider college players prospects until they are signed with their major league organization and start producing in the minors.
6. We do not consider relievers top 100 prospects because nearly all of them need to fail as starting prospects first.
7. We do not rank anyone that has already hit the majors this year as I am assuming that someone in your league has grabbed them on the waiver wire.

ORGPOSSiegelRankCollettePOSORG
BALPDylan Bundy1Billy HamiltonOFCIN
TEXSSJurickson Profar2Jurickson ProfarSSTEX
KCOFWil Myers3Dylan BundyPBAL
STLOFOscar Taveras4Oscar TaverasOFSTL
CINOFBilly Hamilton5Wil MyersOFKC
MIN3BMiguel Sano6Miguel Sano3BMIN
PITPGerrit Cole7Trevor BauerPARI
ARIPTrevor Bauer8Gerrit ColePPIT
SEAPTaijuan Walker9Taijuan WalkerPSEA
SEAPDanny Hultzen10Jameson TaillonPPIT
STLPShelby Miller11Danny HultzenPSEA
PITPJameson Taillon12Nolan Arenado3BCOL
ARIPTyler Skaggs13Archie BradleyPARI
TORCTravis d'Arnaud14Nick CastellanosOFDET
COLOFNolan Arenado15Francisco LindorSSCLE
ARIPArchie Bradley16Jose FernandezPFLA
DETSSNick Castellanos17Shelby MillerPSTL
SEACMike Zunino18Travis d'ArnaudCTOR
FLAPJose Fernandez19Zack WheelerPNYM
CLESSFrancisco Lindor20Tyler SkaggsPARI
NYMPZack Wheeler21Jake OdorizziPKC
FLAOFChristian Yelich22Christian YelichOFFLA
KCPJake Odorizzi23Mike Olt3BTEX
WAS3BAnthony Rendon24Nick FranklinSSSEA
TEX3BMike Olt25Carlos MartinezPSTL
SD3BJedd Gyorko26Anthony Rendon3BWAS
BOSSSXander Bogaerts27Julio TeheranPATL
SEASSNick Franklin28James PaxtonPSEA
SEAPJames Paxton29Jonathan Singleton1BHOU
HOU1BJonathan Singleton30Xander BogaertsSSBOS
LADPZach Lee31Jedd Gyorko3BSD
STLPCarlos Martinez32Kolten Wong2BSTL
MINOFByron Buxton33Jake MarisnickOFTOR
HOUSSCarlos Correa34Jesse BiddlePPHI
BOSOFJackie Bradley35Mike ZuninoCSEA
TORPNoah Syndergaard36Zach LeePLAD
NYYOFMason Williams37Mason WilliamsOFNYY
STL2BKolten Wong38Oswaldo ArciaOFMIN
TOROFJake Marisnick39Gary SanchezCNYY
NYYCGary Sanchez40Chris ArcherPTB
BOSOFBryce Brentz41Brett JacksonOFCHC
BOSPMatt Barnes42Bubba StarlingOFKC
SDOFRymer Liriano43Bryce BrentzOFBOS
BALPKevin Gausman44Matt BarnesPBOS
CHCOFBrett Jackson45Jackie BradleyOFBOS
PHIPJesse Biddle46Eddie Rosario2BMIN
SEASSBrad Miller47Jorge SolerOFCHC
MINOFOswaldo Arcia48Wily PeraltaPMIL
COLSSTrevor Story49Javier BaezSSCHC
SDPRobbie Erlin50Trevor StorySSCOL
CHCOFJorge Soler51Leonys MartinOFTEX
MIN2BEddie Rosario52Gary BrownOFSF
NYYPManny Banuelos53Cody BuckelPTEX
TEXPCody Buckel54Noah SyndergaardPTOR
KCPYordano Ventura55Kevin GausmanPBAL
TEXPMartin Perez56Tyler ThornburgPMIL
HOUOFGeorge Springer57Robbie ErlinPSD
ATLPJulio Teheran58Brad PeacockPOAK
PHIPTrevor May59Jorge BonifacioOFKC
TBPTaylor Guerrieri60A.J. ColePOAK
CINPTony Cingrani61Casey KellyPSD
MILPTyler Thornburg62Allen WebsterPLAD
HOUPJarred Cosart63Taylor GuerrieriPTB
CHCSSJavier Baez64Justin NicolinoPTOR
TORPJustin Nicolino65Kyle CrickPSF
TORPAaron Sanchez66Dan StrailyPOAK
ATLPArodys Vizcaino67Matt Davidson3BARI
LADOFYasiel Puig68Hak-Ju LeeSSTB
KCOFBubba Starling69Cory Spangenberg2BSD
CINPRobert Stephenson70Aaron SanchezPTOR
NYYOFTyler Austin71Alen HansonSSPIT
HOU2BDelino DeShields, Jr.72Delino DeShields2BHOU
SDPPCasey Kelly73George SpringerOFHOU
SFOFGary Brown74David HolmbergPARI
TBPChris Archer75Daniel CorcinoPCIN
LAA3BKaleb Cowart76Daniel NorrisPTOR
CINPDaniel Corcino77Henry OwensPBOS
PITSSAlen Hanson78Tony CingraniPCIN
KCOFJorge Bonifacio79Arodys VizcainoPATL
LADOFJoc Pederson80Joc PedersonOFLAD
SFPKyle Crick81Aaron HicksOFMIN
WASPAlex Meyer82Robert StephensonPCIN
OAKPDan Straily83Ryan LavarnwayCBOS
ARI3BMatt Davidson84Michael ChoiceOFOAK
LADPAllen Webster85Rymer LirianoOFSD
NYMSSWilmer Flores86Gregory PolancoOFPIT
WASOFBrian Goodwin87Jarred CosartPHOU
TEXPBarret Loux88Tyler AustinOFNYY
STLPTrevor Rosenthal89Brad MillerSSSEA
ARIPDavid Holmberg90Jimmy NelsonPMIL
LAA1BC.J. Cron91C.J. Cron1BLAA
COLOFKyle Parker92Michael WachaPSTL
OAKOFMichael Choice93Yasiel PuigOFLAD
TEXOFLeonys Martin94Josh SaleOFTB
PITOFGregory Polanco95Trevor RosenthalPSTL
BOSPHenry Owens96Garin Cecchini3BNYM
PITPLuis Heredia97Yordano VenturaPKCR
NYMPMichael Fulmer98Michael FulmerPNYM
OAK1BMiles Head99Kyle GibsonPMIN
STLPMichael Wacha100Cheslor Cuthbert3BKC
Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Jason Collette
Jason has been helping fantasy owners since 1999, and here at Rotowire since 2011. You can hear Jason weekly on many of the Sirius/XM Fantasy channel offerings throughout the season as well as on the Sleeper and the Bust podcast every Sunday. A ten-time FSWA finalist, Jason won the FSWA's Fantasy Baseball Writer of the Year award in 2013 and the Baseball Series of the Year award in 2018 for Collette Calls,and was the 2023 AL LABR champion. Jason manages his social media presence at https://linktr.ee/jasoncollette
Jesse Siegel
Siegel covers college football, college basketball and minor league baseball for RotoWire. He was named College Sports Writer of the Year by the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers
Collette Calls: Thinking About Pitchers Returning From Injuries
Collette Calls: Thinking About Pitchers Returning From Injuries
MLB DFS Picks: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Wednesday, October 30
MLB DFS Picks: DraftKings Plays and Strategy for Wednesday, October 30