ADP Battles: Metcalf vs. Cooper vs. Pickens

ADP Battles: Metcalf vs. Cooper vs. Pickens

This article is part of our ADP Analysis series.

Most fantasy managers go into drafts with some type of cheat sheet, but let's face it, even with your order of players listed in advance, we all question similarly ranked players when we're on the clock. The goal of this series is to lay out the upside and downside of players who have similar ADPs. When comparing players, we'll break down players at the same position because fantasy managers typically have a good idea of which position they're targeting with a specific pick.

For those looking for a strong wide receiver after the top 20 (or so) are off the board, this ADP battle is for you. We'll compare DK Metcalf, Amari Cooper and George Pickens.

DK Metcalf, WR, Seahawks

Upside

Even though Metcalf had a 1,303-yard, 10-touchdown season in 2020, that production appears to be a career outlier. We can usually look for 1,000-1,100 yards and about seven scores from the pass-catcher. If new offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb goes with a more aggressive and heavier passing attack we could see Metcalf thrive. In that scenario, don't be surprised if the physical receiver ends up in the 1,200-yard range. Also, Metcalf is always capable of scoring double-digit touchdowns.

Downside

Geno Smith had the only two good seasons of his long career when Shane Waldron was running the offense. If Grubb is unable to unlock his quarterback in the same way as Waldron, we could see regression from the 33-year-old signal-caller. If that happens, Metcalf could find himself

Most fantasy managers go into drafts with some type of cheat sheet, but let's face it, even with your order of players listed in advance, we all question similarly ranked players when we're on the clock. The goal of this series is to lay out the upside and downside of players who have similar ADPs. When comparing players, we'll break down players at the same position because fantasy managers typically have a good idea of which position they're targeting with a specific pick.

For those looking for a strong wide receiver after the top 20 (or so) are off the board, this ADP battle is for you. We'll compare DK Metcalf, Amari Cooper and George Pickens.

DK Metcalf, WR, Seahawks

Upside

Even though Metcalf had a 1,303-yard, 10-touchdown season in 2020, that production appears to be a career outlier. We can usually look for 1,000-1,100 yards and about seven scores from the pass-catcher. If new offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb goes with a more aggressive and heavier passing attack we could see Metcalf thrive. In that scenario, don't be surprised if the physical receiver ends up in the 1,200-yard range. Also, Metcalf is always capable of scoring double-digit touchdowns.

Downside

Geno Smith had the only two good seasons of his long career when Shane Waldron was running the offense. If Grubb is unable to unlock his quarterback in the same way as Waldron, we could see regression from the 33-year-old signal-caller. If that happens, Metcalf could find himself right around 1,000 yards and six touchdowns. That would be a fine season, but nothing fantasy managers would see as a fair return on investment.

The Bottom Line

It seems we know what to expect from Metcalf. He likely won't be the megastar we hoped for after his monster 2020 season. However, the former Ole Miss standout is one of the safer receivers on the board. Plus, durability has not been an issue with Metcalf, who has missed only one game in five seasons. 

Amari Cooper, WR, Browns

Upside

Cooper has played amazing football during his two years with the Browns. The former Alabama star is averaging 75 catches, 1,205 yards and seven touchdowns since 2022. Last year, the veteran played five games with Deshaun Watson at quarterback. In four of those games, Cooper posted at least 90 yards despite having double-digit targets in just one of those contests. As the top receiver in an offense that has provided him 130 targets per season, Cooper could flirt with a 1,300-yard season.

Downside

Cooper has fallen below 1,114 yards and five touchdowns just once in the last five seasons. The fact the wideout has thrived with the Browns going through a carousel of quarterbacks has proven Cooper's star status. Even if the receiver fell behind his recent production, a worst-case scenario would be 1,050 yards and five touchdowns. 

The Bottom Line

For some reason, the fantasy community continues to reject the idea of Cooper being a top-15 receiver. The numbers he has consistently produced are, at worst, those of a top-20 receiver. Consider Cooper as one of the biggest values in 2024 drafts.

George Pickens, WR, Steelers

Upside

Very few receivers can do the level of damage after the catch Pickens has achieved. In 2023, the wideout had an 89th percentile yards after the catch rate. The fact Pickens was able to post 1,140 yards on 106 targets that came from Kenny Pickett and Mason Rudolph speaks to the pass-catcher's level of ability. Many fantasy managers are concerned the former Georgia Bulldog will fall onto hard times with run-centric coach Arthur Smith leading the Steelers' offense. Don't forget that when Smith coached A.J. Brown with Ryan Tannehill, Brown had a pair of seasons with at least 1,051 yards and eight touchdowns despite seeing no more than 106 targets. One of the ways this offense helped Brown was by hitting him on slants and deep shots off play-action passes. It would seem Russell Wilson (the presumed starter) will be successful on those types of throws. In terms of upside, Pickens may match last year's 1,140 yards and 106 targets, but the touchdowns could be near 10.

Downside

Since Pickens has already shown the ability to produce in a terrible offense, projecting a truly bad season is difficult. However, if Wilson struggles to succeed in the offense and/or Justin Fields takes over, the offense may not be able to consistently get the wideout into optimal situations to gain yardage after the catch. If the quarterback play is worse than expected, the receiver could struggle to reach 1,000 yards and five touchdowns.

The Bottom Line

The Steelers lack elite weapons in the passing game aside from Pickens. That should ensure the receiver eclipses 100 targets. With Pittsburgh likely leaning heavily on the run, the pass-catcher should find room to get open and gain yards after the catch. The play-action game should help the quarterbacks get clean looks to find Pickens as well. There may not be a massive upside due to the history of Smith's offenses, but Pickens should be a value at his typical draft cost. 

The Final Word

Cooper appears to possess both the highest floor and ceiling of this group. Not only is he the top option in this group, but a case can be made that Cooper should be drafted in a higher tier. Although it is very close between Metcalf and Pickens, it seems probable Metcalf will see more targets. That is enough to move Metcalf into the No. 2 spot in this battle. The likely lack of ceiling, especially in an Arthur Smith offense, is what moves Pickens to the last spot in this group.

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jim Coventry
Coventry was a finalist for the FSWA football writer of the year in 2022. He started playing fantasy football in 1994 and won a national contest in 1996. He also nabbed five top-50 finishes in national contests from 2008 to 2012 before turning his attention to DFS. He's been an industry analyst since 2007, though he joined RotoWire in 2016. A published author, Coventry wrote a book about relationships, "The Secret of Life", in 2013.
Streaming Defenses: Week 11 Fantasy Options for Team Defenses
Streaming Defenses: Week 11 Fantasy Options for Team Defenses
NFL Injury Analysis:  Tread Carefully With Collins
NFL Injury Analysis: Tread Carefully With Collins
NFL Waiver Wire: Week 11 Pickups
NFL Waiver Wire: Week 11 Pickups
Interview with a DFS Standout: How to Win DFS NFL Showdown Contests
Interview with a DFS Standout: How to Win DFS NFL Showdown Contests