Fantasy Football
Fantasy Sports
DFS
Sports Betting
Picks & Props
Sign Up
The Composite RotoWire 200: Updated Overall Rankings List

The Composite RotoWire 200: Updated Overall Rankings List

Written by 
Chris Liss 
Updated on August 30, 2012 1:19AM EST
Four RotoWire Staff members weighed in with their top-200 overall players in a 12-14 team league with standard scoring (no PPR). Assume 1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1 FLEX (RB/WR/TE), 1 TE. (No K or Defense). Unranked players were counted as No. 210 for the purposes of the composite average.

Feedback is welcome.

RankPayneHooverLissStopaCompositeAverage
1Arian FosterAaron RodgersArian FosterArian FosterArian Foster1.25
2Ray RiceArian FosterCalvin JohnsonAaron RodgersAaron Rodgers3.25
3LeSean McCoyRay RiceLeSean McCoyCalvin JohnsonRay Rice3.75
4Calvin JohnsonTom BradyRay RiceTom BradyCalvin Johnson4
5Aaron RodgersDrew BreesAaron RodgersLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoy4.25
6Tom BradyLeSean McCoyChris JohnsonRay RiceTom Brady5.5
7Chris JohnsonCalvin JohnsonDarren McFaddenDrew BreesDrew Brees7.25
8Drew BreesJulio JonesTom BradyChris JohnsonChris Johnson7.5
9Darren McFaddenChris JohnsonDrew BreesJimmy GrahamDarren McFadden11.25
10Adrian PetersonJimmy GrahamTrent RichardsonRob GronkowskiJimmy Graham11.75
11Jimmy GrahamCam NewtonA.J. GreenDarren McFaddenJulio Jones15.75
12DeMarco MurrayVictor CruzJulio JonesMatt ForteRob Gronkowski16
13Cam NewtonJordy NelsonLarry FitzgeraldMaurice Jones-DrewLarry Fitzgerald16
14Marshawn LynchMarshawn LynchMatt ForteJamaal CharlesMarshawn Lynch16.25
15Larry FitzgeraldRob GronkowskiHakeem NicksGreg JenningsA.J. Green17.75
16A.J. GreenMatthew StaffordVictor CruzA.J. GreenMatt Forte17.75
Four RotoWire Staff members weighed in with their top-200 overall players in a 12-14 team league with standard scoring (no PPR). Assume 1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1 FLEX (RB/WR/TE), 1 TE. (No K or Defense). Unranked players were counted as No. 210 for the purposes of the composite average.

Feedback is welcome.

RankPayneHooverLissStopaCompositeAverage
1Arian FosterAaron RodgersArian FosterArian FosterArian Foster1.25
2Ray RiceArian FosterCalvin JohnsonAaron RodgersAaron Rodgers3.25
3LeSean McCoyRay RiceLeSean McCoyCalvin JohnsonRay Rice3.75
4Calvin JohnsonTom BradyRay RiceTom BradyCalvin Johnson4
5Aaron RodgersDrew BreesAaron RodgersLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoy4.25
6Tom BradyLeSean McCoyChris JohnsonRay RiceTom Brady5.5
7Chris JohnsonCalvin JohnsonDarren McFaddenDrew BreesDrew Brees7.25
8Drew BreesJulio JonesTom BradyChris JohnsonChris Johnson7.5
9Darren McFaddenChris JohnsonDrew BreesJimmy GrahamDarren McFadden11.25
10Adrian PetersonJimmy GrahamTrent RichardsonRob GronkowskiJimmy Graham11.75
11Jimmy GrahamCam NewtonA.J. GreenDarren McFaddenJulio Jones15.75
12DeMarco MurrayVictor CruzJulio JonesMatt ForteRob Gronkowski16
13Cam NewtonJordy NelsonLarry FitzgeraldMaurice Jones-DrewLarry Fitzgerald16
14Marshawn LynchMarshawn LynchMatt ForteJamaal CharlesMarshawn Lynch16.25
15Larry FitzgeraldRob GronkowskiHakeem NicksGreg JenningsA.J. Green17.75
16A.J. GreenMatthew StaffordVictor CruzA.J. GreenMatt Forte17.75
17Rob GronkowskiLarry FitzgeraldJimmy GrahamJordy NelsonTrent Richardson18.5
18Victor CruzDarren McFaddenGreg JenningsMarshawn LynchVictor Cruz18.75
19Julio JonesSteven JacksonMarshawn LynchLarry FitzgeraldCam Newton18.75
20Trent RichardsonFred JacksonMichael TurnerDeMarco MurrayDeMarco Murray20.5
21Brandon MarshallMatt ForteDeMarco MurrayRoddy WhiteJamaal Charles21.5
22Matthew StaffordTrent RichardsonRob GronkowskiTrent RichardsonGreg Jennings23.25
23Jamaal CharlesJamaal CharlesAhmad BradshawHakeem NicksAdrian Peterson25
24Matt ForteBrandon MarshallCam NewtonJulio JonesJordy Nelson25.25
25Michael TurnerMatt RyanAndre JohnsonAdrian PetersonMaurice Jones-Drew26.5
26Maurice Jones-DrewDoug MartinJamaal CharlesAndre JohnsonBrandon Marshall26.5
27Fred JacksonGreg JenningsRyan MathewsCam NewtonAndre Johnson28.25
28Doug MartinA.J. GreenPercy HarvinMichael TurnerHakeem Nicks28.25
29Ahmad BradshawDeMarco MurrayBrandon MarshallVictor CruzFred Jackson28.5
30Steven JacksonBrandon LloydDoug MartinMichael VickMichael Turner29
31Andre JohnsonAndre JohnsonAdrian PetersonDarren SprolesRoddy White30.5
32Roddy WhiteMarques ColstonMaurice Jones-DrewBrandon MarshallDoug Martin31
33Greg JenningsRoddy WhiteFred JacksonAaron HernandezMatthew Stafford33.5
34Hakeem NicksAdrian PetersonJordy NelsonFred JacksonPercy Harvin34.5
35Wes WelkerMaurice Jones-DrewMarques ColstonAntonio BrownSteven Jackson35.75
36Ryan MathewsPercy HarvinRoddy WhitePercy HarvinRyan Mathews36.75
37Jordy NelsonPeyton ManningWes WelkerWes WelkerMarques Colston37
38Percy HarvinEli ManningJeremy MaclinMike WallaceAhmad Bradshaw40.25
39Marques ColstonEric DeckerDemaryius ThomasRyan MathewsWes Welker40.5
40Willis McGaheePeyton HillisSteve SmithDoug MartinBrandon Lloyd45
41Michael VickHakeem NicksMike WallaceJermichael FinleyAaron Hernandez46
42Antonio GatesAntonio GatesSteven JacksonMarques ColstonDez Bryant47.5
43Frank GoreMichael TurnerSteve JohnsonMiles AustinAntonio Brown47.75
44Stevan RidleyAntonio BrownMiles AustinMatthew StaffordDeMaryius Thomas49
45Shonn GreeneRyan MathewsDez BryantAhmad BradshawAntonio Gates50.25
46Brandon LloydStevan RidleyAaron HernandezBrandon LloydFrank Gore50.5
47BenJarvus Green-EllisDemaryius ThomasAntonio GatesSteve SmithMichael Vick52.5
48Darren SprolesDez BryantFrank GoreDez BryantSteve Smith54.25
49Dez BryantAaron HernandezMichael VickSteve JohnsonMike Wallace54.5
50Demaryius ThomasDarren SprolesAntonio BrownPhilip RiversPeyton Manning54.75
51Jeremy MaclinDonald BrownReggie BushReggie BushDarren Sproles55.25
52Reggie BushJermichael FinleyMatthew StaffordSteven JacksonStevan Ridley55.5
53Eric DeckerWes WelkerStevan RidleyEli ManningSteve Johnson56.5
54Dwayne BoweTorrey SmithDeSean JacksonPeyton ManningEli Manning56.5
55Peyton ManningPhilip RiversTorrey SmithFrank GoreWillis McGahee56.75
56Aaron HernandezFrank GoreDonald BrownDwayne BoweJeremy Maclin57.5
57Philip RiversBenJarvus Green-EllisC.J. SpillerIsaac RedmanEric Decker57.5
58Miles AustinShonn GreeneBrandon LloydDeSean JacksonPhilip Rivers57.75
59Mark IngramDarrius Heyward-BeyDwayne BoweJeremy MaclinReggie Bush57.75
60Vincent JacksonWillis McGaheeReggie WayneDemaryius ThomasMiles Austin58
61Eli ManningIsaac RedmanVincent JacksonDonald BrownDonald Brown58.5
62Antonio BrownSteve SmithWillis McGaheeTony RomoTorrey Smith59.25
63Fred DavisMike WallaceVernon DavisTorrey SmithMatt Ryan61.75
64Steve JohnsonAhmad BradshawPierre GarconC.J. SpillerDwayne Bowe62.25
65Torrey SmithVernon DavisEric DeckerWillis McGaheeVincent Jackson65
66Donald BrownRyan WilliamsPeyton HillisVincent JacksonC.J. Spiller66.75
67Jonathan StewartC.J. SpillerMalcom FloydVernon DavisShonn Greene67
68Steve SmithTony RomoMichael CrabtreeBen RoethlisbergerIsaac Redman67.25
69Matt RyanDavid WilsonPhilip RiversMatt RyanBenJarvus Green-Ellis69
70DeSean JacksonSteve JohnsonRobert MeachemAntonio GatesDeSean Jackson69.5
71Ryan WilliamsBen RoethlisbergerRobert GriffinMark IngramJermichael Finley70.75
72Jason WittenAndrew LuckEvan RoysterGreg LittleVernon Davis70.75
73Rashad JenningsVincent JacksonPeyton ManningEric DeckerPeyton Hillis74
74Isaac RedmanCedric BensonEli ManningReggie WayneJonathan Stewart75.5
75Ben TateRashad JenningsRashad JenningsBen TateReggie Wayne75.75
76Mike WallaceJustin BlackmonCedric BensonJonathan StewartTony Romo76.25
77Kevin SmithReggie BushIsaac RedmanShonn GreeneMark Ingram78
78Peyton HillisJonathan StewartDeAngelo WilliamsDeAngelo WilliamsBen Tate78.25
79C.J. SpillerMikel LeshoureRoy HeluStevan RidleyRyan Williams78.5
80Greg LittleDwayne BoweBen TateLance MoorePierre Garcon78.75
81DeAngelo WilliamsPierre GarconJonathan StewartKevin SmithDeAngelo Williams80.25
82Pierre GarconJeremy MaclinMark IngramRoy HeluDarrius Heyward-Bey82.75
83Reggie WayneBen TateJustin BlackmonDarrius Heyward-BeyRobert Griffin83.75
84Evan RoysterDeAngelo WilliamsMatt RyanMichael CrabtreeFred Davis86.25
85David WilsonFred DavisKenny BrittBenJarvus Green-EllisDavid Wilson86.75
86Cedric BensonReggie WayneTony RomoRobert GriffinRashad Jennings87.5
87Robert GriffinMiles AustinBenJarvus Green-EllisRyan WilliamsKevin Smith88
88Vernon DavisToby GerhartShonn GreenePierre GarconCedric Benson88.75
89Tony RomoKyle RudolphBeanie WellsMalcom FloydMichael Crabtree90.5
90Michael BushMichael VickRyan WilliamsToby GerhartBen Roethlisberger91.25
91Brandon PettigrewRobert GriffinDarrius Heyward-BeyDenarius MooreGreg Little92
92Nate WashingtonMichael CrabtreeDarren SprolesBeanie WellsJason Witten93.25
93Santonio HolmesJermaine GreshamKevin SmithDavid WilsonEvan Royster93.5
94Jermichael FinleyLeGarrette BlountSidney RiceEvan RoysterToby Gerhart94.25
95Toby GerhartJason WittenFred DavisCarson PalmerRobert Meachem95.25
96Sidney RiceDeSean JacksonJermichael FinleyJay CutlerMalcom Floyd100
97Jon BaldwinKenny BrittNate WashingtonMatt SchaubBeanie Wells103
98Darrius Heyward-BeyMichael BushSantonio HolmesDanny AmendolaSantonio Holmes103.75
99Carson PalmerPierre ThomasDenarius MooreJason WittenMichael Bush104
100Beanie WellsMark IngramDavid WilsonJermaine GreshamNate Washington105
101Kenny BrittKevin SmithJon BaldwinBrandon PettigrewSidney Rice105
102Denarius MooreJacquizz RodgersRandall CobbFred DavisKenny Britt105
103Anquan BoldinRobert MeachemGreg LittleRobert MeachemPierre Thomas108.25
104Jay CutlerMike WilliamsToby GerhartAnquan BoldinAndrew Luck108.75
105Robert MeachemJared CookAustin CollieSantonio HolmesRandall Cobb110
106Jared CookRandall CobbMichael BushJonathan DwyerJermaine Gresham110.25
107Randall CobbJonathan DwyerJason WittenOwen DanielsJon Baldwin110.5
108Mike WilliamsTony GonzalezIsaiah PeadNate WashingtonDenarius Moore111.25
109Jacob TammeJake LockerTitus YoungAndrew LuckMike Williams111.25
110Pierre ThomasJon BaldwinBen RoethlisbergerBrent CelekJustin Blackmon112.25
111Mikel LeshoureDoug BaldwinPierre ThomasJacob TammeMikel LeShoure113
112Felix JonesTitus YoungLance MoorePeyton HillisCarson Palmer114.25
113Brian QuickGreg LittleRobert TurbinPierre ThomasBrandon Pettigrew115.75
114Malcom FloydRussell WilsonMikel LeshoureDaniel ThomasRoy Helu116
115Jermaine GreshamSidney RiceMike WilliamsSidney RiceAnquan Boldin116.5
116Ben RoethlisbergerKendall HunterKendall WrightEmmanuel SandersLance Moore117.25
117Doug BaldwinKendall WrightBrandon LaFellJoe FlaccoShane Vereen120
118Michael CrabtreeShane VereenShane VereenMike WilliamsJay Cutler120.25
119Brent CelekSantonio HolmesBraylon EdwardsCedric BensonJacob Tamme123.25
120Justin BlackmonGreg OlsenFelix JonesJared CookLeGarrette Blount123.75
121Shane VereenJay CutlerJames StarksTony GonzalezTitus Young124.5
122Tony GonzalezCarson PalmerRandy MossMichael BushTony Gonzalez125.75
123Brandon LaFellNate WashingtonAnquan BoldinShane VereenDoug Baldwin126
124Alfred MorrisEvan RoysterDoug BaldwinJacquizz RodgersJared Cook126.5
125Santana MossAlfred MorrisSantana MossRandall CobbJacquizz Rodgers129.75
126Stephen HillTim HightowerAndrew LuckDevery HendersonBrandon LaFell131.25
127Laurent RobinsonRoy HeluJacquizz RodgersRashad JenningsBrent Celek132
128Andrew LuckJacob TammeMike GoodsonEarl BennettKendall Wright132.75
129Michael FloydBrandon LaFellStephen HillLeGarrette BlountJonathan Dwyer135
130Ronnie HillmanMalcom FloydRueben RandleMike GoodsonFelix Jones136.75
131Jacoby FordBeanie WellsBrandon PettigrewTaiwan JonesIsaiah Pead137.25
132LeGarrette BlountIsaiah PeadBrent CelekIsaiah PeadDaniel Thomas137.25
133Owen DanielsDaniel ThomasJermaine GreshamKendall HunterMatt Schaub137.25
134Titus YoungMatt SchaubKendall HunterJon BaldwinSantana Moss139
135Dustin KellerJoe FlaccoRonnie HillmanRonnie BrownRonnie Hillman139.75
136Lance MooreAnquan BoldinJonathan DwyerEd DicksonAlfred Morris142
137Montario HardestyRonnie HillmanAlex GreenKenny BrittDanny Amendola143.5
138Kendall WrightLeonard HankersonRonnie BrownBilal PowellRobert Turbin145
139Kyle RudolphSteven SmithMario ManninghamAlex GreenRonnie Brown147.5
140Greg OlsenBrandon PettigrewLeGarrette BlountJames StarksAlex Green147.5
141Jake LockerLance MooreCarson PalmerJonathan BaldwinBrian Quick148
142Kellen WinslowBraylon EdwardsEmmanuel SandersRandy MossKendall Hunter148.25
143Ronnie BrownT.Y. HiltonRashard MendenhallTitus YoungMike Goodson148.5
144Rueben RandleGolden TateBernard PierceRussell WilsonLaurent Robinson148.5
145Coby FleenerDanny AmendolaJacob TammeAndy DaltonJake Locker149.25
146Russell WilsonMike GoodsonCoby FleenerRyan FitzpatrickRussell Wilson149.5
147Legedu NaaneeSantana MossDevery HendersonJosh FreemanGreg Olsen150.5
148Daniel ThomasJosh GordonBrian QuickMikel LeshoureDevery Henderson150.75
149Devery HendersonRandy MossBrian HartlineAlfred MorrisKyle Rudolph151.75
150Brandon GibsonDavone BessTaiwan JonesMario ManninghamAustin Collie152.75
151Matt SchaubRobert TurbinLaMichael JamesAustin CollieMichael Floyd152.75
152Alshon JefferyAlex GreenTony GonzalezDoug BaldwinStephen Hill154
153Robert TurbinDenarius MooreMichael FloydLaurent RobinsonOwen Daniels155.25
154Davone BessDustin KellerDaniel ThomasBrian HartlineRandy Moss155.75
155Mario ManninghamLaurent RobinsonLegedu NaaneeJames JonesCoby Fleener156.5
156Andre RobertsBrian QuickEarl BennettBrandon LaFellEmmanuel Sanders158
157Delone CarterFelix JonesJacoby FordRonnie HillmanMario Manningham159
158Martellus BennettMichael FloydLamar MillerFelix JonesRueben Randle162.5
159Lamar MillerRyan BroylesLaurent RobinsonSantana MossTaiwan Jones164
160Brandon JacobsKeshawn MartinJay CutlerKendall WrightJosh Freeman164.5
161Jerome SimpsonAlshon JefferyJake LockerAlex SmithAlshon Jeffery164.5
162Alex GreenJerome SimpsonJerome SimpsonSteve BreastonEarl Bennett166.75
163Josh FreemanRyan FitzpatrickT.Y. HiltonRobert TurbinDavone Bess166.75
164Austin CollieEmmanuel SandersLeonard HankersonMartellus BennettAndy Dalton167.25
165Taiwan JonesDamian WilliamsMontario HardestyGreg OlsenMontario Hardesty167.25
166Jacquizz RodgersRueben RandleKeshawn MartinAlshon JefferyBraylon Edwards167.75
167Josh GordonBrent CelekMatt SchaubCoby FleenerJacoby Ford168
168Keshawn MartinCoby FleenerSteve BreastonDustin KellerJoe Flacco168
169Danny AmendolaAndy DaltonDavone BessKyle RudolphJosh Gordon168.25
170Leonard HankersonJosh FreemanAlfred MorrisJustin BlackmonJames Starks170.25
171Rod StreaterJames JonesJavon RingerMichael FloydLeonard Hankerson170.5
172Bernard ScottDavid NelsonTim TebowDevin HesterJerome Simpson171
173Brandon TateEarl BennettAndy DaltonJordan ShipleyRashard Mendenhall173.25
174Le'Ron McClainRonnie BrownDion LewisJacoby FordBrian Hartline174.5
175Tony MoeakiKellen WinslowJared CookBrian QuickMartellus Bennett174.5
176Roy HeluMartellus BennettKellen WinslowTim TebowKellen Winslow175.75
177Isaiah PeadStephen HillGreg OlsenLaMichael JamesKeshawn Martin176
178Jackie BattleKnowshon MorenoJosh FreemanBrandon JacobsT.Y. Hilton178.5
179Dion LewisRashard MendenhallAlshon JefferyBernard ScottJames Jones179.25
180Kevin OgletreeDexter McClusterSteven SmithJavon RingerLegedu Naanee180.5
181Ryan BroylesDevery HendersonJames JonesMontario HardestyRyan Fitzpatrick182.25
182Andy DaltonAlex SmithEddie RoyalRashard MendenhallTim Hightower183.75
183David NelsonChristian PonderNate BurlesonDion LewisSteve Breaston183.75
184Donald JonesBilal PowellNick ToonStephen HillDion Lewis183.75
185Keiland WilliamsBrian HartlineJoe McKnightChristian PonderLamar Miller184.25
186Christian PonderMontario HardestyDelone CarterJake LockerDavid Nelson184.5
187Joel DreessenMike TolbertOwen DanielsMatt CasselBrandon Jacobs184.5
188Mike TolbertBrandon JacksonMarvin JonesJoel DreessenSteven Smith184.75
189Rashard MendenhallDavid GettisTim HightowerMarcedes LewisBilal Powell185.5
190Mike GoodsonAndre RobertsBrandon JacobsDavid NelsonAndre Roberts186.5
191Jonathan DwyerAustin CollieDonnie AveryScott ChandlerLaMichael James187
192Roberto WallaceMario ManninghamDallas ClarkBrandon WeedenBernard Pierce189.25
193Bernard PierceMohamed SanuDavid NelsonBen WatsonBernard Scott189.25
194Donnie AveryOwen DanielsRussell WilsonDavone BessRyan Broyles190
195Jason AvantSteve BreastonChris IvoryDallas ClarkAlex Smith190.75
196Daryl RichardsonMatt CasselBernard ScottKevin WalterDelone Carter190.75
197Michael SmithGreg SalasDamian WilliamsDeion BranchChristian Ponder191
198Montell OwensChris IvoryMohamed SanuT.Y. HiltonEd Dickson191.5
199Donald DriverDion LewisBrandon TateJerome SimpsonTim Tebow192
200Chris IvoryRamses BardenMartellus BennettBraylon EdwardsJavon Ringer192.75
Golden Tate193.5
Damian Williams195.5
Brandon Tate198
Mike Tolbert198.75
Joel Dreessen198.75
Kevin Ogletree200.25
Rod Streater200.25
Matt Cassel200.75
Chris Ivory200.75
Jordan Shipley200.75
Le'Ron McClain201
Tony Moeaki201.25
Dallas Clark201.75
Knowshon Moreno202
Dexter McCluster202.5
Mohamed Sanu202.75
Nate Burleson203.25
Nick Toon203.5
Donald Jones203.5
Joe McKnight203.75
Keiland Williams203.75
Brandon Jackson204.5
David Gettis204.75
Scott Chandler205.25
Brandon Weeden205.5
Roberto Wallace205.5
Ben Watson205.75
Jason Avant206.25
Kevin Walter206.5
Daryl Richardson206.5
Deion Branch206.75
Greg Salas206.75
Michael Smith206.75
Montell Owens207
Donald Driver207.25
Ramses Barden207.5

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Chris Liss
Chris Liss
Chris Liss was RotoWire's Managing Editor and Host of RotoWire Fantasy Sports Today on Sirius XM radio from 2001-2022.
NFL Expert Picks: Christmas Special - Chiefs vs. Steelers; Ravens vs. Texans
NFL Expert Picks: Christmas Special - Chiefs vs. Steelers; Ravens vs. Texans
Survivor: Week 17 Strategy & Picks
Survivor: Week 17 Strategy & Picks
NFL DFS Breakdown: Christmas Matchups
NFL DFS Breakdown: Christmas Matchups
NFL Game Previews: Thursday Night Matchup
NFL Game Previews: Thursday Night Matchup