The RotoWire Blog has been retired.

These archives exist as a way for people to continue to view the content that had been posted on the blog over the years.

Articles will no longer be posted here, but you can view new fantasy articles from our writers on the main site.

Opportunity-Neutral Fantasy Football Rankings

There are essentially four variables that determine a player's value: (1) Health; (2) Skills; (3) Team Context; and (4) Role. Of the four, (1) and (4) are most subject to dramatic change, but health is usually both unpredictable and obvious, so let's set that aside for the moment and focus on role.

A player's role determines the quantity of his opportunities (team context determines quality), and quantity of opportunity is a huge factor in value. Once you get beyond the league's elite players, projecting roles becomes difficult, and this is even before we take into account frequent role changes due to other players' injuries. For that reason, it's good to have an idea of who the players are and where they are independent of their immediate roles. To that end, I've ranked the top-20 QB, top-30 RB, top-30 WR and top-20 TE irrespective of roles, i.e., assuming everyone had an equal number of basic opportunities. For QBs, that's 550 passing attempts, for RBs, that's 250 carries, for WRs and TEs, that's 130 targets:

Here's how I'd rank them:

QBRBWRTE
1Aaron RodgersJamaal CharlesJordy NelsonRob Gronkowski
2Russell WilsonLeSean McCoyDemaryius ThomasJimmy Graham
3Colin KaepernickMatt ForteJulio JonesJulius Thomas
4Robert GriffinAdrian PetersonCalvin JohnsonVernon Davis
5Cam NewtonMontee BallJosh GordonLaDarius Green
6Nick FolesDeMarco MurrayAlshon JefferyZach Ertz
7Peyton ManningArian FosterMichael FloydDwyane Allen
8Andrew LuckGiovani BernardDez BryantJordan Cameron
9Drew BreesShane VereenAJ GreenMartellus Bennett
10Jay CutlerC.J. SpillerKeenan AllenKyle Rudolph
11Phillip RiversAndre EllingtonKenny StillsGreg Olsen
12Tony RomoChristine MichaelDeSean JacksonJordan Reed
13Johnny ManzielCarlos HydePercy HarvinDennis Pitta
14Alex SmithPierre ThomasCordarelle PattersonCharles Clay
15Ben RoethlisbergerRashad JenningsT.Y. HiltonTyler Eifert
16Matt RyanReggie BushJeremy Maclin
17Tom BradyJoique BellJordan Matthews
18Ryan TannehillKnile DavisTerrance Williams
19EJ ManuelRyan MathewsAaron Dobson
20Michael VickDavid WilsonRiley Cooper
21Doug MartinRueben Randle
22Eddie LacyJustin Hunter
23Donald BrownJustin Blackmon
24CJ AndersonMike Evans
25Ronnie HillmanMichael Crabtree
26Robert TurbinVincent Jackson
27Charles SimsBrandon Marshall
28James StarksCody Latimer
29Ben TateKenny Britt
30Terrance WestJermaine Kearse

There are some issues with this framework (Would Shane Vereen really get 250 carries even if every other RB on the Patriots dropped dead? And why then did I leave off Darren Sproles?), but for the most part it's a list of players with the most upside, opportunity being equal. That favors running QBs, efficient-passing QBs and QBs with good weapons. RBs who catch passes, are suited to goal-line work and play in good offenses get boosted, as do WRs with good size/speed profiles and good quarterbacks.

It also shows which top players are simply a product of their roles and who are in danger of losing significant value should their opportunities shrink even moderately. Matthew Stafford is a volume guy, as is Larry Fitzgerald, Marshawn Lynch and Jason Witten. Consequently, they're absent from these lists.