The RotoWire Blog has been retired.

These archives exist as a way for people to continue to view the content that had been posted on the blog over the years.

Articles will no longer be posted here, but you can view new fantasy articles from our writers on the main site.

RotoWire Steak League Auction

This monstrous 16-team league auction took place nine days ago. It's standard scoring, non-PPR and has three IDPs (1 DL, 1 LB, 1 DB). It's only a $20 buy-in, so more important than winning the league is not losing the sidebet - buying steaks for the teams that finish ahead of you in total points. I'm proud to say in 13 years of doing this league, I've had the indignity of buying my own steak once, and the sorry fate of being a "double" buyer once. The other 11 years, I ate and drank for free, mercilessly running up the tab on whatever poor saps happened to lose out in total points.

So the strategy here is to play it conservatively, especially given how deep the league is, how few bench spots we have (six is not a lot when you have three extra IDP slots to worry about) and how the downside (spending $300-plus on dinner and seeing people purposely run up the bill on you) is greater than the upside. Moreover, the league is split into two divisions each of which has its own steak bet, and the LA division, of which I'm a part, has only five teams in on the bet. Essentially you have a 1 in 5 chance of being a double-buyer and 2 in 5 chance of being a single-buyer (pays for himself and one other) or worse. When winning pays about $280 on a 15:1 long shot, but losing costs $300 at 4:1 and at least $200 at 3:2, you play not to lose.

That means you direct most of your $200 budget toward receivers and largely look for values. For that most part that's what I did. Here's the squad:

PosPlayerCost
QBBen Roethlisberger5
RBC.J. Spiller31
RBCarlos Hyde11
WRJulio Jones41
WRAlshon Jeffery31
WRMichael Floyd32
TEDennis Pitta7
KJustin Tucker1
DLJason Pierre-Paul2
LBVontez Burfict3
DBEric Weddle4
BTerrance West13
BJosh Gordon13
BJordan Matthews3
BRyan Fitzpatrick1
BLorenzo Taliaferro1
BChris Polk1

Josh Gordon was probably not a great buy in this format - hard to stash, replacement value is low and as I said, it's more important not to lose than it is to win, but I couldn't help myself. While there's a lot of talk about Shawn Siegele Zero RB Strategy, I think you can get most of its benefits, but less of its downside by essentially employing a one-RB strategy, i.e., draft one early-round back and then mix, match and wait for injuries in the second slot. That's what I did here with C.J. Spiller, whom I trust perhaps more than most do - and then a stable of part timers/back-ups.

The issue with zero RB is while your team will likely get better as injuries happen, and you have a lot of the backups, you're out of luck if most of the carnage happens midseason, rather than early on. Moreover, in a short-bench/deep format, it's particularly ill-suited. But so is trying to be strong at every position in a 16-team league, so I chose to be especially strong at WR, went 1-RB and got unquestioned, reasonably productive starters at TE/QB. I also spent more than most on IDPs, but in truth the $4 Weddle bid was an accident - I meant to go $3 (arguably ill-advised anyway), but when I hit "+1" someone had just upped to three a split second before me.

In any event, I like my chances to eat for free again, knock on wood. When my time comes - and at some point it surely will - it will get sadistic (I'm the one who orders the full shrimp scampi entree as an appetizer, in addition to other regular appetizers).

Here's a table with the full results:

PosTeam Schoenke$PosTeam McKeown$PosSan Francisco Caesers$PosMadison Amendolas$
QBRussell Wilson17QBRobert Griffin27QBTony Romo19QBColin Kaepernick21
RBMarshawn Lynch38RBAdrian Peterson54RBRay Rice17RBJamaal Charles56
RBReggie Bush20RBMaurice Jones-Drew15RBAndre Ellington29RBSteven Jackson13
WRCordarrelle Patterson22WRLarry Fitzgerald21WRJordy Nelson41WRJulian Edelman9
WRBrandon Marshall45WRJeremy Maclin29WRVincent Jackson30WRVictor Cruz27
WRT.Y. Hilton21WREric Decker15WRDwayne Bowe15WRRoddy White23
TEJordan Reed13TEJason Witten11TEZach Ertz16TEJordan Cameron21
LBJerrell Freeman1LBPatrick Willis2LBDanny Trevathan1LBJerod Mayo2
DLJared Allen1DLGreg Hardy3DLMario Williams1DLMuhammad Wilkerson1
DBLaRon Landry1DBEric Berry2DBAntrel Rolle1DBBarry Church1
KAlex Henery1KAdam Vinatieri2KDan Bailey1KStephen Gostkowski3
BERyan Tannehill2BEJohnny Manziel8BEBernard Pierce6BEDevonta Freeman9
BEKhiry Robinson6BEJerricho Cotchery3BEAndy Dalton6BEKnile Davis5
BEChristine Michael6BEMatt Asiata2BEBrandin Cooks8BEJonathan Grimes3
BEDonald Brown4BEMarcus Lattimore2BEBryce Brown2BEJames Jones3
BECharles Sims1BEAndrew Hawkins2BEMalcom Floyd2BEDexter McCluster1
BEKa'Deem Carey1BEMiles Austin2BELance Dunbar5BEDri Archer1
PosTeam Liss$PosThe Champs$PosMonrovia Ickey Shuffle$PosSick of Buying Steak$
QBBen Roethlisberger5QBTom Brady21QBPhilip Rivers12QBAaron Rodgers45
RBC.J. Spiller31RBEddie Lacy50RBDoug Martin31RBArian Foster34
RBCarlos Hyde11RBMontee Ball44RBPierre Thomas13RBRyan Mathews22
WRJulio Jones41WRMichael Crabtree23WRDemaryius Thomas53WRRandall Cobb28
WRAlshon Jeffery31WRTerrance Williams21WRPierre Garcon24WRMarques Colston18
WRJosh Gordon13WRMike Evans11WRMarvin Jones6WRJustin Hunter8
TEDennis Pitta7TEHeath Miller3TERob Gronkowski27TEJulius Thomas26
LBVontaze Burfict3LBDerrick Johnson1LBChad Greenway2LBLawrence Timmons1
DLJason Pierre-Paul2DLLamarr Houston1DLCameron Wake1DLDeMarcus Ware1
DBEric Weddle4DBKenny Vaccaro1DBMark Barron2DBMorgan Burnett1
KJustin Tucker1KSteven Hauschka1KMike Nugent1KPhil Dawson1
BEMichael Floyd32BERonnie Hillman4BETrent Richardson13BEDanny Woodhead5
BETerrance West13BEJames Starks3BETyler Eifert2BEAhmad Bradshaw6
BEJordan Matthews3BEMike Williams4BEMark Ingram9BERoy Helu1
BERyan Fitzpatrick1BEAaron Dobson9BEJake Locker1BEHarry Douglas1
BELorenzo Taliaferro1BEEli Manning2BEAndre Holmes2BEJerick McKinnon1
BEChris Polk1BEJonathan Dwyer1BELatavius Murray1BESteve Johnson1
PosSpringfield Isotopes$PosPay For My Tofu$PosEating Steak, Again$PosPunters for Days$
QBMatthew Stafford24QBAndrew Luck27QBNick Foles27QBCam Newton26
RBAlfred Morris41RBShane Vereen16RBFrank Gore18RBMatt Forte53
RBGiovani Bernard40RBJoique Bell22RBStevan Ridley18RBChris Johnson24
WRKeenan Allen32WRCalvin Johnson50WRA.J. Green46WRAndre Johnson26
WRTorrey Smith24WRMike Wallace18WRDanny Amendola6WREmmanuel Sanders12
WRMarkus Wheaton7WRRueben Randle16WRAnquan Boldin5WRKendall Wright22
TEGreg Olsen11TEMartellus Bennett8TEJimmy Graham45TEVernon Davis18
LBPaul Posluszny2LBKarlos Dansby1LBLuke Kuechly6LBPerry Riley1
DLRobert Quinn4DLChandler Jones2DLRob Ninkovich1DLJ.J. Watt5
DBAaron Williams1DBDeone Bucannon1DBJohnathan Cyprien1DBEarl Thomas1
KMatt Prater2KBlair Walsh1KMason Crosby2KRobbie Gould1
BELadarius Green2BELamar Miller15BEMichael Vick1BESteve Smith4
BEShonn Greene4BEKelvin Benjamin8BEDarren Sproles12BEBilal Powell1
BERobert Woods3BEJeremy Hill11BEGreg Jennings5BEMike Tolbert1
BESam Bradford1BEJoe Flacco2BEJordan Todman3BEJacquizz Rodgers2
BEJermaine Kearse1BERod Streater1BEEddie Royal3BEDavante Adams2
BEJames White1BETravis Kelce1BEC.J. Anderson1BEOdell Beckham1
PosEating 2 Steaks$PosMister Ross$PosTeam McCaigue$PosOSU Sucks$
QBJay Cutler15QBMatt Ryan19QBPeyton Manning45QBDrew Brees40
RBLe'Veon Bell35RBZac Stacy35RBLeSean McCoy59RBDeMarco Murray43
RBBishop Sankey27RBToby Gerhart27RBBen Tate18RBRashad Jennings21
WRPercy Harvin21WRDez Bryant50WRAntonio Brown29WRGolden Tate14
WRDeSean Jackson24WRReggie Wayne10WRMarqise Lee7WRSammy Watkins17
WRWes Welker20WRCecil Shorts10WRKenny Stills7WRRiley Cooper12
TEEric Ebron4TECharles Clay3TEJared Cook1TEKyle Rudolph11
LBBobby Wagner2LBLavonte David5LBLance Briggs7LBJames Laurinaitis1
DLJustin Tuck1DLCameron Jordan3DLSheldon Richardson1DLJadeveon Clowney2
DBKam Chancellor2DBHarrison Smith2DBT.J. Ward2DBCalvin Pryor1
KNick Novak1KGreg Zuerlein1KMatt Bryant1KShayne Graham1
BEFred Jackson4BETre Mason4BEDeAngelo Williams11BEHakeem Nicks10
BEDeAndre Hopkins13BEDarren McFadden9BEBrian Hartline3BEChris Ivory6
BEKnowshon Moreno8BEAndre Williams13BEDoug Baldwin2BETavon Austin13
BEJarrett Boykin6BEKenny Britt7BEAndre Brown2BEEJ Manuel2
BELeGarrette Blount9BEAntonio Gates1BEStepfan Taylor3BEJonathan Stewart3
BEAlex Smith8BEBenny Cunningham1BECarson Palmer2BEGarrett Graham3