MLB Network is reporting that the New York Mets have turned down a deal with the Toronto Blue Jays that would have sent Relief Pitcher Bobby Parnell, Starting Pitcher Jon Niese, OF Fernando Martinez and SS Ruben Tejada to the Blue Jays for Roy Halladay. Can you blame them?
It was reported that the Blue Jays initiated the discussion with the Mets. Usually, it works the other way around. The team with the blue chip waits for the guys who want to play to ante up.
The four players requested by the Mets represent the "cream of the crop" of the Mets farm system.
Parnell-He is currently in the Mets bullpen. He throws a fastball, slider and a split finger with equal success. When he keeps the ball down in the zone, Parnell is very effective. He has work to do on commanding all his pitches. He can throw in the mid-90's. He has a strong enough arm to start or work in relief. The Mets like his future in either role-but probably more in relief. Parnell is the type of pitcher that may have to "settle in" against better quality hitters. That means patience is required as he feels his way through better competition and gains confidence.
Niese-He's a lefty starter with the ability to mix his pitches and set up his change-up with a good, crisp fastball. He can be a dominating pitcher. Not unlike Parnell, Niese has to continue to improve against better quality hitters. He has the ability to work the ball to both sides of the plate and change the hitter's eye level. He's projected as a middle rotation starter, but he's still only 22 years old. He's a good athlete and he 'll make a huge contribution to the Mets rotation when he gets the nod.
Martinez- He has been a top prospect of the organization since he signed as a free agent out of the Dominican Republic in 2005. Martinez is only 20. He has enough bat speed and quick enough wrists to generate power as a left-handed hitter. He has trouble staying healthy and on the field (currently injured.) Martinez doesn't have much speed, so his game will rely on power and good contact. I have never liked his approach at the plate, as I feel he has lacked discipline and plate coverage. However, he is young and projects to be a very good outfielder. I don't see the Mets being too anxious to part with Mr. Martinez.
Ruben Tejada- Tejada is a shortstop with excellent speed and an ability to make things happen. He is only 19 years old, but he plays much older. He is disciplined and patient. He's an exciting player to watch. Tejada plays very good defense to compliment his offensive strengths. He doesn't have much pop in his bat, but this guy has a chance to be very good. How could the Mets ever give him up? I don't think so.
Bottom line-if, in fact the Blue Jays did make that phone call to the Mets, it probably didn't take very long to turn the conversation to other players. It's possible that perhaps two of the above could fetch Halladay, but all four? No way.